Story Published:
May 8, 2003 at 12:12 PM PST
Story Updated:
Jul 24, 2009 at 10:17 AM PST
FRIDAY HARBOR - Sonar from a Navy guided-missile destroyer
apparently agitated a group of killer whales and dozens of
porpoises enough to send them fleeing from the waters southwest of
San Juan Island.
About 20 whales were feeding and behaving normally Monday
morning, when whale-watch operator Tom McMillen lowered an
underwater microphone into the water to listen to their calls.
He picked up a sound he had bever heard before - a high, shrill
whistle that repeated every 25 seconds or so.
"As the sound got louder, the whales gathered up. They do
this when they rest or if there's a stress," McMillen, owner of
Salish Sea Charters, said in a phone interview from Friday Harbor
on Thursday.
Soon after, the orcas started swimming away from the noise.
"They moved north and got out of there," McMillen said. "They
looked distressed."
As many as 100 porpoises leaped through the water, appearing to
distance themselves from the sound.
"The porpoises were going north," McMillen said. "They were
all going the same direction, and they all looked like they were
getting out of there."
As the pinging noise grew louder, McMillen said, he and others
on his boat spotted what appeared to be a Navy ship about 10 miles
away.
Cmdr. Karen Sellers, spokeswoman for Navy Region Northwest,
confirmed the 511-foot USS Shoup was using its sonar "briefly" in
Haro Strait, a body of water just west of San Juan Island, on
Monday. The Everett-based ship was headed to the Canadian Forces
Maritime Experimental Test Range in Nanoose Bay, British Columbia,
she said.
"The Navy is looking into the Shoup's transit in Haro Strait on
May 5 to determine what occured that day," Sellers said. She
declined to comment further.
Use of Navy sonar has come under intense scrutiny since March
2000, when at least 16 whales and two dolphins beached themselves
on an island in the Bahamas. Eight whales died, and scientists
found hemorrhaging around their brains and ear bones, injuries
consistent with exposure to loud noise.
In that case and a similar incident in the Canary Islands off
northwest African last year, Navy ships were present and using a
type of mid-frequency sonar called SQS-53C.
The Navy has not said what type of sonar was used in Haro
Strait.
"Based upon the reports of biolgists on Haro strait, we believe
it may be the same system," said Michael Jasny, a policy analyst
with the Natural Resources Defense Council in Los Angeles.
Meanwhile, the Bush Administration is seeking to exempt the
Department of Defense from five federal laws protecting wildlife
and the environment: the Clean Air Act, the Endangered Species Act,
the Marine Mammal Protection Act and two laws governing cleanup of
toxic waste.
The House Resources Committee passed the bill, sponsored by Rep.
Elton Gallegly, R-Calif., 25-13 on Wednesday.
Rep. Jay Inslee, D-Wash., voted against it.
"Obviously national security is of utmost importance," Inslee
said in a phone interview Thursday, "but if we're going to be
exposing endangered species to risk, we should go the last mile to
look for alternatives" that balance environmental and military
concerns.
The bill has rankled environmental activists.
"Here we have a case where the Navy ran thorough Haro Strait
with their sonar blaring. It was a mistake, but if these exemptions
pass, it won't be considered a mistake because the Navy will be
able to deploy these systems wherever they like - off the coast of
Washington, California, Maine," Jasny said. "There would be
little accountability for the damage that they do."
The National Resources Defense Council and other environemental
groups filed a lawsuit in August 2002 seeking to bar the Navy from
using a powerful, low-frequency sonar system, which travels much
farther than mid- or high-frequency sonar.
In October, a federal judge in San Francisco temporarily blocked
the Navy from deploying low-frequency sonar.
"It is undisputed that marine mammals, many of whom depend on
sensitive hearing for essential activities like finding food and
mates and avoiding predators, and some of whom are endangered
species, will at a minimum be harassed by extremely loud and
far-traveling ... sonar," U.S. Magistrate Elizabeth D. Laporte
wrote.
A hearing is scheduled for late June.