Story Published:
Oct 14, 2005 at 6:08 PM PST
Story Updated:
Aug 31, 2006 at 1:06 AM PST
TACOMA - After long-running legal arguments about
privacy and public disclosure, documents stemming from a probe of a
former Tacoma police chief who killed his wife and himself were
released to the public Friday.
The mass of reports, interview transcripts and other items from
the sprawling investigation showed, in part, that co-workers and
city officials noted David Brame was increasingly withdrawn from
work and consumed by his pending divorce before he fatally shot his
wife, Crystal, and himself on April 26, 2003, in a suburban mall
parking lot.
The documents - thousands of pages compiled on 33 compact discs
- included previously undisclosed city records from an
investigation surrounding the Brame murder-suicide.
The newly released records stem from a State Patrol probe of
alleged misconduct before and after the shootings. The
investigation involved nearly three dozen city and Police
Department employees.
Media outlets, including The News Tribune newspaper of Tacoma
and The Associated Press, had sought the records for months.
Other investigations have revealed that several employees knew
about domestic violence allegations in the Brames' marriage, and an
accusation that the chief had sexually harassed a subordinate.
The State Patrol found no evidence of criminal wrongdoing, but
suggested there was a culture of corruption in city government.
In the newly released documents, Jeannette Blackwell, an
administrative assistant for the chief, said in an interview with
the patrol that Brame called her the night before the shootings and
talked to her for about 45 minutes, until nearly midnight.
Blackwell said Brame mentioned he had been repeatedly watching a
video of his wedding, and talked about an upcoming news story
regarding his wife's domestic violence allegations.
A summary of an interview with Catherine Woodard, who briefly
took over for Brame before retiring on disability, said she had
discussed Brame's foundering work performance with then-City
Manager Ray Corpuz.
Blackwell also discussed Brame's inattentiveness at work, with a
State Patrol interview report saying "many times she actually '...
forced the stuff under his face,' referring to important issues
which demanded immediate action."
The patrol wrapped up its investigation in October 2004, but
then-City Manager Jim Walton refused to release most of the
records, citing the need to protect the privacy of employees.
The city provided limited records between October 2004 and
February 2005, but the names of employees under scrutiny were not
disclosed and most allegations were not released.
In almost all cases, Walton said, the allegations against
employees were not sustained.
Two Tacoma police unions went to court to oppose the release of
the documents, saying they needed to protect the privacy of their
members.
Those arguments eventually were turned aside. The state Court of
Appeals ruled this week that the documents must be released and the
union representing lieutenants and captains decided not to
challenge that ruling.
Mark Langford, president of the Tacoma Police Management
Association, said releasing the records could only harm the
reputation of city police and impair effective law enforcement.
"I've been probably more disappointed by the city's failure to
defend us in this than I was in the judge's ruling," Langford
said. Asked about how the records case has affected morale,
Langford said: "It's not good. It feels like betrayal."
City of Tacoma spokesman Scott Huntley said city officials were
merely following state public disclosure law when they began their
effort to release the Brame documents.
"The law required us to do this and that was clear. And as a
city government, we must follow the law," he said. "We kind of
didn't get ourselves involved in the issue of should or
shouldn't."
Much of the information about internal allegations had been
disclosed through other probes or news reports. But David Zeeck,
executive editor of The News Tribune, said the disclosure was an
important step for open government.
"It's been a long fight to get this out, but we really think
city residents want and need to know how city officials handled
this," he said.
Other records released by the city in the aftermath of the
shootings showed that Brame had been hired by the police department
in 1981 despite flunking a psychological exam, and was steadily
promoted despite a 1988 rape allegation that investigators called
"credible" even though it was never prosecuted.
Corpuz, the former city manager who promoted Brame to chief,
broke more than two years of self-imposed silence last month in a
sworn deposition.
Corpuz said he hesitated for various reasons to act on repeated
warnings from city employees about Brame's erratic behavior, which
included references to Brame's death threats against his wife.
In the deposition, Corpuz said he was suspicious of complaints
from anonymous sources, was skeptical of claims in divorce filings
and feared overreacting to media reports.
The deposition was part of a $12 million agreement that settled
a wrongful-death lawsuit against the city, filed by the family of
Crystal Judson Brame.