Story Published:
Dec 15, 2005 at 4:58 PM PST
Story Updated:
Aug 31, 2006 at 1:09 AM PST
SEATTLE - A young Navy wife was charged Thursday with
second-degree murder in the death of her 18-month-old daughter,
whose body was found stuffed in a garbage bag with some dirty
diapers.
The Kitsap County coroner called it one of the worst neglect
cases he's seen.
Richeal M. Rhoades, who told naval investigators she fell into a
deepening depression after moving to Navy housing in Bremerton last
August with her two young children, entered a not guilty plea in
Kitsap County Superior Court.
The murder count alleges criminal negligence. Rhoades, 21, was
held on $500,000 bail in the Kitsap County jail in Port Orchard,
west of Seattle across Puget Sound.
Her attorney, Aaron Talney, said Rhoades' mental health is a
consideration in the case, although he wouldn't say if she'd been
evaluated.
"It's pretty obvious that was a woman who was pretty distressed
over an extended time," Talney said Thursday in a telephone
interview.
The woman moved to the Jackson Park Naval Housing Area in
Bremerton as her sailor husband Michael Rhoades prepared to leave
from Kings Bay, Ga., aboard the USS Maine, a Trident submarine that
was reassigned to a base at Bangor, near Bremerton.
She told investigators she grew more and more detached from
little Brenda and Michael Jr., age 3, as her depression worsened,
according to court documents. She sought no help for her depression
and, although she knew her daughter had a temperature shortly
before she died late last month, Rhoades said she didn't call a
hospital.
"Richeal said she knew that she had not been taking care of her
kids and that Brenda was suffering from malnutrition and had a bad
diaper rash," Bremerton police Detective Kenny Davis' affidavit
said. "She was afraid that both Brenda and Michael Jr. would be
taken away from her."
The little boy is in protective custody.
Her husband's submarine arrived Sunday at Bangor, and he
apparently learned of the baby's death that night, although
authorities weren't notified until Monday, court papers said.
When officers came to the home Monday and asked about the little
girl, the woman said, "It's in here," and led them to a closet
downstairs. The child's body was found wrapped in garbage bags and
sealed in a packing box.
"It's one of those crimes that you can't understand why it
occurred," Deputy Prosecutor Chris Casad said Thursday. "She
lived in Navy housing and had lots of resources available to her."
The Navy offers free counseling and parenting classes to
sailors' spouses and dependents. An ombudsman program is also
available to provide additional support for families.
Yet despite the wealth of information available from agencies
like the National Institute of Mental Health, depression still goes
undiagnosed in many people, said Wayne Katon, professor of
psychiatry at the University of Washington in Seattle.
"There is still a lot of stigma about depression in society,"
Katon said. "It makes people more reticent to ask for help."
By November, according to Rhoades' account as described in court
documents, she was considering suicide and neglecting Brenda and
Michael.
Michael was feeding himself, she said, and she was giving Brenda
6 eight-ounce bottles of milk a day. That amount declined as days
went by, and she eventually was changing the girl's diaper only
once a day.
A week before Thanksgiving, she said, there were so many dirty
diapers in Brenda's room that she left the window open all night to
air out the stench. The next day, the child had a 102-degree
temperature.
Rhoades said she gave the little girl children's aspirin to help
lower her fever.
Later, she gave Brenda an eight-ounce bottle of milk and left
her in her room with the door closed. She closed Michael in his
room, as well, then went upstairs to sleep.
She estimated the baby was left alone for 40 to 44 hours before
she checked on her and found Brenda dead. The mother said she found
the little girl against the bedroom door and had to push her out of
the way to enter.
"She touched Brenda's chest area and it was cold," court
documents said. "She said she knew that Brenda was dead, she had
killed her from not feeding her or taking proper care of her."
The detective's affidavit said Rhoades described putting the
baby's body in a black garbage sack with several dirty diapers,
then leaving it in the bedroom.
Rhoades said she then went upstairs and played an online game,
Final Fantasy XI.
Rhoades later had Thanksgiving dinner with neighbors, telling
them the little girl was sick and staying with friends.
Autopsy results on the child are not expected for several weeks,
said Greg Sandstrom, Kitsap County coroner since 1994.
"This is probably one of the worst neglect cases we've ever
seen in my career here," he said.