State's Smoking Ban Sends Puffers To Idaho

Summary

Washington smokers facing a ban on lighting up in bars and restaurants are taking their habit - and money - to Idaho.

Story Published: Jan 5, 2006 at 10:59 AM PST

Story Updated: Aug 31, 2006 at 1:10 AM PST

CLARKSTON, WASH. - Washington smokers facing a ban on lighting up in bars and restaurants are taking their habit - and money - to Idaho.

"I've had regular clientele tell me right to my face they're going to Idaho to smoke," Tony Salerno, owner of Hogan's in Clarkston, told the Lewiston Tribune.

Washington voters approved Initiative 901 in November, which bans smoking within 25 feet of doorways, windows and air intakes of public places and workplaces. It took effect Dec. 8.

That has left some establishments in Washington near the Idaho border having to compete with bars and restaurants in Idaho that allow smoking.

Salerno measured out a spot where people could stand and smoke, but that caused the sidewalk to be littered with cigarette butts and garbage. He said lunch and dinner crowds haven't increased enough to replace patrons that went to Idaho. Now he's trying to bring in more customers with music on additional nights.

"Trying to survive on one good night out of six isn't going to cut it," he said.

Smitty's Barrel had to let go of four employees, said manager Kelleigh Fowler.

"We're almost going out of business, it's been so bad," she said. "Our biggest money night is New Year's Eve, and we had 10 people in here and did less than $300 in business from opening to close."

Clarkston Police Chief Joel Hastings said the department has received some complaints about smokers in illegal areas, and officers did find people smoking in one tavern. The business owner was given a warning.

Despite the ban, some businesses are doing fine.

Station 3, which serves lunch and dinner and has some gambling, has made up for disappearing smokers with people coming to eat who wouldn't have entered before the ban.

"We have a good reputation for our food, and it's saved us," said owner Tom Scher.

But Scher said the anti-smoking law is too broad and could put some bars and restaurants out of business.

Fowler said she wrote a letter, which has been signed by patrons of Smitty's and other taverns, and plans to send it to state representatives and senators requesting that the law be modified. If that results in any action, though, she said it might not be in time to help Smitty's.

"We could be closed in three months," she said. "You never know."