Story Published:
Mar 9, 2006 at 6:26 AM PST
Story Updated:
Aug 31, 2006 at 1:14 AM PST
SEATTLE - A prominent suburban pediatrician whose medical
license was suspended amid claims that he had improper
relationships with troubled adolescent boys he was treating will
give up his license and retire, his lawyer says.
By permanently surrendering his license, Dr. Bill S. Schnall,
60, of Shoreline, will settle a case that was scheduled to go
before the state Medical Quality Assurance Commission next Monday,
according to a statement issued Wednesday by his lawyer, John
Gagliardi.
Schnall's license was suspended in August by the panel, which
accused him of violating physician-patient boundaries and standards
of medical care with eight adolescent patients. He could still face
criminal charges, and a lawsuit is pending.
The doctor continues to "adamantly deny that his interactions
with patients have ever been sexually motivated as implied in the
initial charges," Gagliardi's statement said.
Schnall, a married father of two daughters, practiced medicine
for nearly 30 years, most recently at the Richmond Pediatric
Clinic, was president of the medical staff at Children's Hospital
in 2002 and was a member of the Shoreline School Board in 1989-96.
In his initial response to the state panel he maintained that he
tried only to be a friend, mentor and advocate for the young men of
high school and college age who were cited in the complaint. He
denied accusations that he masturbated in front of a patient or
forced that young man to masturbate.
Schnall decided to surrender his license "rather than
subjecting himself, his family, his colleagues and most
importantly, the multiple patients that were unwillingly brought
into this matter by the state to the stress and public spectacle
that likely would attach to a public hearing," Gagliardi said.
As part of the settlement, the state panel dropped all charges
except one, that Schnall practiced outside the standard of care by
"violating appropriate physician patient boundaries," and
eliminated any reference to sexual motivation, the lawyer said.
The commission will announce the settlement formally Thursday,
spokesman Donn Moyer said.
"If we get what we're after, which is putting that person out
of practice, they can say what they want," Moyer told The Seattle
Times. "We would not bring charges if we didn't think we could
prove them."
Dan Donohoe, spokesman in the King County prosecutor's office,
said no decision had been made on whether to bring criminal charges
pending further review.
Anne Bremner, a lawyer for a former patient who filed a
malpractice lawsuit against Schnall in Superior Court in January,
said she was relieved by the license surrender.
"Justice, for the family I represent, is so much tied to Dr.
Schnall not doing this to anybody else," Bremner said.