Prosecutor: Bales had victims' blood on him after killing spree
»Play Video
JOINT BASE LEWIS-McCHORD, Wash. (AP) - A caped figure captured on surveillance video came running out of the darkness to the edge of a remote Army outpost in southern Afghanistan. Blood was smeared on his face, prosecutors said, and soaked into his clothes.
Less than a mile away, 16 Afghans, including nine children, were dead, some of their bodies on fire in two villages.
As fellow soldiers stopped him at the base's gate, Staff Sgt. Robert Bales was incredulous, prosecutors said. Then, as he was taken into custody, Bales said: "I thought I was doing the right thing."
The details, from a prosecutor as well as Bales' comrades, emerged Monday as a preliminary hearing in his case opened, offering the clearest picture yet of one of the worst atrocities of the Iraq and Afghanistan wars.
The attack on March 11 prompted the U.S. to halt combat operations for days in the face of protests, and it was a month before military investigators could reach the crime scenes.
Bales, 39, faces 16 counts of premeditated murder and six counts of attempted murder. The hearing could last up to two weeks and will help determine whether the case goes to a court martial.
The defense did not give an opening statement.
Bales has not entered a plea. His attorneys have not discussed the evidence, but say Bales has post-traumatic stress disorder and suffered a concussive head injury during a prior deployment to Iraq.
The father of two from Lake Tapps, Wash., wore green fatigues and sat beside one of his civilian lawyers as an investigating officer read the charges against him and informed him of his rights.
When asked if he understood them, Bales said, "Sir, yes, sir."
Bales spent the March night before the raids at Camp Belambay, watching "Man On Fire," a fictional account of a former CIA operative on a revenge spree, with his fellow soldiers, said Lt. Col. Jay Morse, the prosecutor.
He seemed normal as they shared whiskey, discussed Bales' anxiety over whether he'd get a promotion and talked about another soldier who lost his leg a week earlier in a roadside bomb attack, Cpl. David Godwin testified.
Shortly before leaving the base, Bales told a Special Forces soldier that he was unhappy with his family life and that the troops should have been quicker to retaliate for the March 5 bomb attack, Morse said.
"At all times, he had a clear understanding of what he was doing and what he had done," said Morse, who described Bales as lucid and responsive.
Bales is accused of slipping away from the remote outpost with an M-4 rifle outfitted with a grenade launcher to attack the villages of Balandi and Alkozai, in a dangerous district.
Morse said Bales broke the killings into two episodes. Dressed in a T-shirt, Bales walked first to one village, return to the base and then slipped away again to carry out the second attack.
Between the episodes, Bales told a colleague about shooting people at one of the villages, Morse said. The soldier apparently took it as a bad joke and responded: "Quit messing around."
Prosecutors played for the first time the video captured by a surveillance blimp that showed the caped figure running toward the base, then stopping and dropping his weapons as he was confronted. There was no audio.
It wasn't immediately clear from where Bales got the cape.
As he stood outside the base, Godwin testified, Bales had asked him and another soldier: "Did you rat me out? Did you rat me out?"
Part of the hearing will be held overnight to allow video testimony from witnesses, including an estimated 10 to 15 Afghans, in Afghanistan.
Bales' attorney, John Henry Browne, said the hearing will give the defense a chance to see what the military can prove. He said they are expecting a court martial.
The Ohio native joined the Army in late 2001 - after the 9/11 attacks - as his career as a stockbroker imploded, including an arbitrator's $1.5 million fraud judgment against him and his former company.
Bales was serving his fourth combat tour after three stints in Iraq and his arrest prompted a national discussion about the stresses that soldiers face from multiple deployments.
His lawyers have said Bales remembers little or nothing from around the time of the attacks.
Emma Scanlan, one of his attorneys, declined to say to what extent the lawyers hope to elicit testimony that could be used to support a mental-health defense. Bales himself will not make any statements.
She said the Army had only recently turned over a preliminary DNA trace evidence report from the crime scenes, but defense experts have not had time to review it.
Less than a mile away, 16 Afghans, including nine children, were dead, some of their bodies on fire in two villages.
As fellow soldiers stopped him at the base's gate, Staff Sgt. Robert Bales was incredulous, prosecutors said. Then, as he was taken into custody, Bales said: "I thought I was doing the right thing."
The details, from a prosecutor as well as Bales' comrades, emerged Monday as a preliminary hearing in his case opened, offering the clearest picture yet of one of the worst atrocities of the Iraq and Afghanistan wars.
The attack on March 11 prompted the U.S. to halt combat operations for days in the face of protests, and it was a month before military investigators could reach the crime scenes.
Bales, 39, faces 16 counts of premeditated murder and six counts of attempted murder. The hearing could last up to two weeks and will help determine whether the case goes to a court martial.
The defense did not give an opening statement.
Bales has not entered a plea. His attorneys have not discussed the evidence, but say Bales has post-traumatic stress disorder and suffered a concussive head injury during a prior deployment to Iraq.
The father of two from Lake Tapps, Wash., wore green fatigues and sat beside one of his civilian lawyers as an investigating officer read the charges against him and informed him of his rights.
When asked if he understood them, Bales said, "Sir, yes, sir."
Bales spent the March night before the raids at Camp Belambay, watching "Man On Fire," a fictional account of a former CIA operative on a revenge spree, with his fellow soldiers, said Lt. Col. Jay Morse, the prosecutor.
He seemed normal as they shared whiskey, discussed Bales' anxiety over whether he'd get a promotion and talked about another soldier who lost his leg a week earlier in a roadside bomb attack, Cpl. David Godwin testified.
Shortly before leaving the base, Bales told a Special Forces soldier that he was unhappy with his family life and that the troops should have been quicker to retaliate for the March 5 bomb attack, Morse said.
"At all times, he had a clear understanding of what he was doing and what he had done," said Morse, who described Bales as lucid and responsive.
Bales is accused of slipping away from the remote outpost with an M-4 rifle outfitted with a grenade launcher to attack the villages of Balandi and Alkozai, in a dangerous district.
Morse said Bales broke the killings into two episodes. Dressed in a T-shirt, Bales walked first to one village, return to the base and then slipped away again to carry out the second attack.
Between the episodes, Bales told a colleague about shooting people at one of the villages, Morse said. The soldier apparently took it as a bad joke and responded: "Quit messing around."
Prosecutors played for the first time the video captured by a surveillance blimp that showed the caped figure running toward the base, then stopping and dropping his weapons as he was confronted. There was no audio.
It wasn't immediately clear from where Bales got the cape.
As he stood outside the base, Godwin testified, Bales had asked him and another soldier: "Did you rat me out? Did you rat me out?"
Part of the hearing will be held overnight to allow video testimony from witnesses, including an estimated 10 to 15 Afghans, in Afghanistan.
Bales' attorney, John Henry Browne, said the hearing will give the defense a chance to see what the military can prove. He said they are expecting a court martial.
The Ohio native joined the Army in late 2001 - after the 9/11 attacks - as his career as a stockbroker imploded, including an arbitrator's $1.5 million fraud judgment against him and his former company.
Bales was serving his fourth combat tour after three stints in Iraq and his arrest prompted a national discussion about the stresses that soldiers face from multiple deployments.
His lawyers have said Bales remembers little or nothing from around the time of the attacks.
Emma Scanlan, one of his attorneys, declined to say to what extent the lawyers hope to elicit testimony that could be used to support a mental-health defense. Bales himself will not make any statements.
She said the Army had only recently turned over a preliminary DNA trace evidence report from the crime scenes, but defense experts have not had time to review it.
Just free the man.Â
Lt. Calley was find guilty of killing 109 of the 500 plus civilians at My Lai, which were orders but never proved as per coverup. The public outrage was so great for the verdict that Lt..Calley only served a little over 3 years of house arrest. Staff Sgt Bales was not following orders or in charge of any kind of operation against the enemy other than a vindicative act against innocent civilians...
 @Windowseat What information do you have that indicates (a) Sgt Bales did this, (2) he was not following orders or in charge of an operation against the enemy, (3) that this was a vindictive act?  I prefer to see all the facts instead of guessing as you do.  I am sure you would feel very bad if information came to light that proved he did not do this.  Alas, since this is a US Army investigation we are talking about, that will probably never happen.  I do not know what he did, as I was not there.  However, if you read my comment, based upon what I have read, this whole thing stinks to high hell.
This whole story stinks......Things to consider: (1) The base where he assigned to was a  a special ops base in a very dangerous area. (2) I am supposed to believe that he just up and decided to leave the safety of  a secure compound (with a surveillance blimp  stationed above the base), by himself.  (3) I have a hard time believing that no one noticed or thought it was odd that this guy was leaving a secure compound (at night), by himself, armed only with a rifle and a sidearm. (4) We are talking about Afghanistan; even our "allies" (the Afghans), don't seem to like us very much. And yet, this guy supposedly makes the decision  to leave the compound by himself, strolling along armed and evidently wearing a cape no less.  The area where this occurred is a hazardous area for anyone, especially an American Soldier.  Since this is the US Army we are talking about, let me remind everyone that the powers that be decided to issue drugs to soldiers.  Drugs.  To soldiers.  With automatic weapons.  They do this repeatably.  Remember Pat Tillman?  Played for the Arizona Cardinals NFL team?  He volunteered for the Army, became a Army Ranger, and was killed in a firefight.  According to official accounts. he was killed by enemy action.  But low and behold, the real truth was that he was shot in the back of the head by a fellow trooper (the real story came to light when Pat's parent's were getting the runaround.  With  the help of intense media focus,  the Army admitted that the official report was a fabrication).   The Army lied about the cause of death, made him a hero, then covered it up.  Same with Jessica White, the Army soldier who was taken as a POW in the early stages of the 2nd Iraqi invasion.  Official  Army reports indicated that she fired her weapon until she ran out of ammo, then was captured.  Not true.  Ms. White stills  feels compelled to set the record straight: they surrendered rather quickly.  Our Government and military are not what they use to be. I think this guy was made the fall guy.  By the way, I am a former USAF Special Ops officer (12 years), with 137 combat sorties. Â
Â
I agree with a lot you are saying (13F4V RET) How can an E-6 walk willie nillie off and on a remote outpost? Why is the entire chain of command not right with him? The whole thing stinks. I call scrape goat on a failed special op. Bad intel on enemy position did not confirm went in and  killed local woman and kids could not blame Taliban.
Also why drag his civilian past into it? Oh to paint him in the bad light.
 @BocaBob Exactly!  I think you are on to something about the failed special op - I seem to recall that initial reports indicated that there were others, according to villagers statements.  I would like to think a op gone bad is the probable answer, but I also reluctantly think that maybe some of the gung ho special ops guys were looking for a little payback.
I've got a friend on that base. Its easy to come and go pretty much as you please. The civilians are not allowed off the base without an escort. They have almost daily mortar attacks but the Afghans never seem to be able to hit anything. The biggest problem is that we just don't belong there. There's nothing to do. Bring the kids home and end this fake war. @Pegasus
 @Blindman  @Pegasus Come and go as you please?  Daily mortar attacks and you can still wander off base as you please?  Don't think so, or maybe the military is geting a little slack at understanding perimeter security. Â
 @Blindman  @Pegasus We don't belong there? I guess you don't care if the Taliban retake the country and provide al-Qaeda with a safe haven. Hippies like you make this country suck.
 @SolntsevskayaBratva ROFL dude, double your dosage
 @Pegasus  @Blindman My comment wasn't even directed towards you. It was to blindman.Â
 @SolntsevskayaBratva  @Blindman Hippie?  Boy your way off the mark.  I guess you didn't get to the end of my comment DA.  Former USAF -12 years, I have served in 4 conflicts from Panama in '89, to Bosnia.  Are you former military?  Seems to me that you were fed a little to much of the BS that our government generates.  BTW; Taliban means "Students of God".  I was there in 1986 - helping our "mujaheddin" buddies - the USAF declared all their block 1 stingers "obsolete", gave them to these boys.  they hated us then too, but appreciated the aid.  They hate all westerners,  with good reason.  Maybe instead being spoon fed more BS from our state media outlets,  you should know whats going on before you sound off.
Suppose it was an Afgan who snuck onto the base and killed 16 servicepeople? Every one here would be crying out for their death. But because he was an American soldier then "poor him". I hope they court martial him and put him away for the rest of his life. Snap or not there is no excuse for what he did. He wasn't on a mission. He wasn't being fired at. He has no proof that any of the victims had done anything worth being killed for. He deserves to be punished. Personal responsibility folks.
There is no proof other some crappy pics that there are any victims. How can convict him on what has been put out by a propaganda machine. Let the real facts rise before you throw him away. Maybe he did it in which case I agree. The rest of his chain of command is as responsible.. E-6 equals staff sgt not Sergeants Major of the Army. He should not have been allowed to leave his post armed or not . Especially x2 Â and that is just for starts. Take the time to learn about S.O.P. and R.O.E. and a little UCMJ.
If Bales goes on trial, then shouldn't every Air Force pilot who dropped a daisy-cutter be scrutinized? War is very messy. The true criminals are the policticians who start the wars.
Â
I say put Karl Rove and Dick Cheney on trial before Bales.
 @MidnightRambler Seriously? Are you going to compare pilots following a lawful order with a mental breakdown soldier going on a killing spree against civilians? War may be messy but civilians are not fair targets.
@Larry*X*KÂ Agreed....civilians are not fair targets. The question is, how can you prosecute a soldier who kills civilians during a mental breakdown and not prosecute the leaders who give orders that will intentionally kill more civilians than Bales every thought of.
Â
i.e. Mi Lai 4, Dresden Firebombing, WWII carpet bombing, study your military history.Â
I'll bet drugs will be brought up during the trial. A lot of our servicemen are on prescription drugs for PTSD and depression. Now more soldiers are dieing from suicide than are dieing from combat injuries. That right there tells you there are serious problems with these fake wars.
This is such a sad case all around. The innocent lives lost in Afghanistan from this massacre; All the trauma this man had been put through in his previous deployments to make him snap... Just sad. My prayers are with all of the families involved.
I am trying not to condemn or rush to judgment  (after the Art. 32 I will probably feel differently).  No one can explain this, there is no rational sense to make of it. I was not there (never been to Afghanistan)  but I see those children every time I read about this or see a headline and my heart aches for themâ¦I, like everyone else, just want the war to end.
@schramalot We may pull out of Afghanistan, but the war with radical Islam will never end. It has been going on since the 7th century BC, and wil continue until one side or the other is wiped out.
@70MonteCarlo Mohammad Ibn Abdallah was born in the year 570 AD, not BC.
Â
Islam is a young religion which is a false belief considering that Jesus said that no other profit would follow Him. He also warned of false profits which would include Mohammad.
@caphillkid @komoispropaganda as usally from a butt hurt dweller
caphillkid, If he was a snakeoil salesman, he must have been a good one.. because there is a widely distributed book that has quite a bit of the things he did in it...
Christianity a Jewish cult?
As far as what was done in Afganistan,...Sad all the way around, for Staff Sgt Bales, and all the innocent Afganis that have been killed.. who are not part of the action going on, but mere spectators of the violence that plagues their country.
Â
 @komoispropaganda Did you ever stop to think that Jesus was a false prophet snake oil salesman just like all the other men that come forward in history with tales of talking to God?
Â
Do Christians really not understand that Christianity is nothing but a Jewish cult?Â
 @komoispropaganda And Joseph Smith?Â