Disabled residents fighting to stop health care cuts
»Play Video
SEATTLE -- On the University of Washington campus, the all-terrain vehicle you'll find along the waterfront has a very unlikely owner.
"I kind of just remember waking up in the ICU," said Aditya Ganapathiraju, recalling a motorcycle crash he was in 10 years ago. "I was going through an intersection just two blocks from my house. I went into the side of a car that was coming out in front of me."
Ganapathiraju broke three vertebrae, one of which damaged his spinal cord, paralyzing him below the chest. It took years of therapy and rehab for him to regain some strength and movement and, most importantly, to become independent again.
A crucial element of that, he says, was in-home, state-funded health care; with both his parents deceased, it allowed the 20-something college student to stay out of elderly nursing homes, where he might otherwise be.
"There are a lot of vulnerable folks who rely on this service," Ganapathiraju said. "It's unfair, of course, that the situation is how it is. It's understandable that there are political forces at work."
Ganapathiraju is referring to state-mandated budget cuts, which slashed in-home personal health care services for the elderly and the disabled. A judge upheld that the cuts are legal, but the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals overturned that decision, arguing that the cuts violate the Americans with Disabilities Act.
The state has until September 17 to appeal the case to the U.S. Supreme Court, said Carl Peterson with the Autistic Self-Advocacy Network. Peterson joined with other advocates for the disabled Wednesday to call on the state and the governor to not appeal the decision.
"What really is at stake here is the ability for somebody with a disability to stay and live fruitfully and as a positive part of the community instead of living in an institution," Peterson said. "We understand that the governor needs to save money and stuff but this is not the way to do it."
A spokeswoman for Gregoire said the state is still weighing options and deciding whether to appeal, but that Gregoire remains a supporter for the rights of the disabled.
"Even after the budget crisis hit our state and a range of cuts averaging 10 percent were made, Washington was still providing up to 393 hours per month of paid help with personal care and household activities such as dressing, bathing, eating, grooming, cooking, housekeeping, and shopping," wrote Karina Shagren, a spokeswoman for the governor, in an email.
Ganapathiraju, who now works for UW in rehab medicine, says the decision - and possible appeal - could impact all Washington residents.
"This affects everyone and anyone in a sense because anyone can become disabled or have a significant disability in the blink of an eye," he said. "It's a risky decision and I don't think it's in the best interest of Washingtonians."
"I kind of just remember waking up in the ICU," said Aditya Ganapathiraju, recalling a motorcycle crash he was in 10 years ago. "I was going through an intersection just two blocks from my house. I went into the side of a car that was coming out in front of me."
Ganapathiraju broke three vertebrae, one of which damaged his spinal cord, paralyzing him below the chest. It took years of therapy and rehab for him to regain some strength and movement and, most importantly, to become independent again.
A crucial element of that, he says, was in-home, state-funded health care; with both his parents deceased, it allowed the 20-something college student to stay out of elderly nursing homes, where he might otherwise be.
"There are a lot of vulnerable folks who rely on this service," Ganapathiraju said. "It's unfair, of course, that the situation is how it is. It's understandable that there are political forces at work."
Ganapathiraju is referring to state-mandated budget cuts, which slashed in-home personal health care services for the elderly and the disabled. A judge upheld that the cuts are legal, but the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals overturned that decision, arguing that the cuts violate the Americans with Disabilities Act.
The state has until September 17 to appeal the case to the U.S. Supreme Court, said Carl Peterson with the Autistic Self-Advocacy Network. Peterson joined with other advocates for the disabled Wednesday to call on the state and the governor to not appeal the decision.
"What really is at stake here is the ability for somebody with a disability to stay and live fruitfully and as a positive part of the community instead of living in an institution," Peterson said. "We understand that the governor needs to save money and stuff but this is not the way to do it."
A spokeswoman for Gregoire said the state is still weighing options and deciding whether to appeal, but that Gregoire remains a supporter for the rights of the disabled.
"Even after the budget crisis hit our state and a range of cuts averaging 10 percent were made, Washington was still providing up to 393 hours per month of paid help with personal care and household activities such as dressing, bathing, eating, grooming, cooking, housekeeping, and shopping," wrote Karina Shagren, a spokeswoman for the governor, in an email.
Ganapathiraju, who now works for UW in rehab medicine, says the decision - and possible appeal - could impact all Washington residents.
"This affects everyone and anyone in a sense because anyone can become disabled or have a significant disability in the blink of an eye," he said. "It's a risky decision and I don't think it's in the best interest of Washingtonians."
If Gregoire appeals, it makes her OUR ENEMY. Â Any attack on the Olmstead decision makes the aggressor an enemy to ALL disabled Americans. Â That decision confirmed and enshrined in law the right of ALL disabled Americans to live and be supported and accommodated in the community, LIVING AMONGST THE GENERAL PUBLIC. Â It is our RIGHT, AS YOUR EQUALS, TO LIVE AMONG YOU.
Â
If this was a proposal to bring back Jim Crow laws (which the end of Olmstead would allow against disabled people), how many of you would fight it?
 @Ishvaara Based on the caregiver hours that DSHS is willing to provide, our AG and Governor would be spending half their day in a bed with a brief (so they don't soil the bed) with no one to tend to them if needs arise. I think after waking up the next day and able to get out of bed on their own, things they take for granted will have a whole new meaning.
Â
Â
 @Ishvaara If the AG and Governor would allow themselves to be wheelchair bound, fed and toileted for a day, maybe they would have a different perspective about the needs of the disabled. Just a thought.
Â
Â
Â
Â
Medicaid isn't going away and it time for state employees to show fiscal responsibility with state and federal funds. This Medicaid study done a few years ago is worth the read.
http://www.northwestliving.info/MedicaidUnsettlingScores.pdf
Nice political move Greggy and the Dems - try to push something thru you know will fail just so you can say you and your cronies tried... Sorry but your smoke and mirrors are not working!!
This is absolutely hilarious to see the commenters here wanting to blame everyone except where the blame should fall. That is directly on Christine Gregoire. She is the one who is unwilling to cut the actual fat out of the budget but cuts things that will only hurt people. The main reason she is doing this is to force tax increases. It's time to boot her ugly butt out of office and not replace her with her clone (Inslee)
 @Gino Policy is just that. It's how it's implemented where the problem lies. DSHS over spends like there is no tomorrow and when challenged, they say the disabled are too needy and should gathered up and put into group homes.
Â
Â
Â
Â
Funny how none of the commenters here have anything to say about the irony of this in light of the passage of and the supreme courts ratification of Obama care. Oh, thats right, this is republican bashing story; silly me!
This has been the Dems plan, especially Gregiore all along. Fail to trim fat off of useless programs, and cut out services like this that are actually needed. I feel for this young man and I hope that he will be able to remain at home.Â
If Romney is elected it will only get worse.
 @LeftisBest It will only get worse if Inslee is elected......
I wonder how our Attorney General - who would be the one to file this appeal - feels about this issue? Or is he too busy running for a new job to bother...and then he can complain that this is just "another Democrat screw up"...
 @OrcasThunder He has known about Athena's case for over a year. I sent him a detailed case history over a month ago and never received a response. All I can hope for is a change in administration that will take the management of our State Medicaid program seriously.
Â
It's comforting to know that my Daughter isn't the only victim of our State's management of Medicaid. Athena and I have been living this nightmare for almost three years with a sadistic twist. I started a thread on a legal forum seeking advice and direction if your interested in another chapter of the dark side of heath care reform.
Â
http://www.isitlegalto.com/washington-state-laws-legal-forum-washington-laws/27613-varo-infraction.html
Â
@John Spikowski Oh John! I really cried reading your story. I am so sorry! Something has got to be done about this - I wish I could do something but it sounds like you're done a lot. It's maybe timel to do like LocalLady says here - take it to the media.
 @Elaine2 What amazes me the most is the level of cruelty shown our family by DSHS. For example, I asked Athena's case worker if a family friend could stop by and pick up a chair that Athena isn't using and in the way and a box of family pictures. Athena's X-husband/DPOA had already chatted with Athena about it and she wanted me to have these items. My friend drove 100 miles as a favor to our family and was turned away because the case worked didn't call and authorize it. Why DSHS is micro managing Athena's life is beyond me. The reason I was called by the ER when Athena was abandoned is due to her DSHS case worker forgetting to schedule a caregiver for her that day.
Â
Â
@John Spikowski:Â
Â
WOW! How absolutely HORRIBLE!
Â
While the ACLU says they cannot help you, I would STRONGLY recommend you contact ALL the local news stations as well as the Seattle Times with your story. It sounds like shining light on the corruption of APS is LONG overdue in your case.
Â
I hope this can be resolved in your favor, once & for all. Too bad there is no way to "inflict" punitive damages on APS. It sounds like they aer simply another gangrenous arm of DSHS & as such needs to be lopped off.
Â
 @LocalLady "I would STRONGLY recommend you contact ALL the local news stations as well as the Seattle Times with your story."
Â
I think everyone is too busy trying to get elected to care about a Dad losing a daughter to the State. I have tried to contact the following politicians and news teams. To be fair, my inquires for the most part were sent via web forms that go to aids and staff that sort out what should be forwarded on.
Â
WA AG
ACLU
WA Governor
WA Dem. Candidate for Governor
WA Dem. Candidate for AG
KING5
KIRO7
KOMO (this story)
Â
Â
They probably won't appeal. 8th Amendment will squash a state, and the fact is that the elderly vote is more important to Washington politicos than some of our other programs.
Motorcycles are dangerous.  He took the risk.  He probably ran the light when he hit the car.  Why should his healthcare bills be  my problem? Â
 @Patches Pal Dude, this guy could be you.
HINT: We have evolved as a society beyond survival of the fittest.Â
I don't know of anyone standing in line waiting to be disabled.
Â
@Patches Pal You're worse than a troll.
 @Patches Pal Wow, great assumptions you make. The only thing you say that makes sense is "motorcycles are dangerous." You have no information to back up the rest of your accusations. It's just as likely that the other car ran the red light or stop sign.Â
 @Patches Pal Great strawman but a quick easy search indicates no civil, non-criminal, or criminal cases in Washington courts for one Aditya Ganapathiraju.
Â
Why should I pay for you when you get sick? What you don't think I do? When you use insurance you cause higher premiums for all - so unless you're now going to tell us that:
Â
a) You're a cyborg who never, ever, EVER goes to the doctor, or even to the dentist for a teeth cleaning
Â
b) You don't have any health insurance, you pay for services at a doc in the box in cash and because of "a" above its a non-issue
Â
Changing a light bulb on a ladder is dangerous too - are you suggesting I don't do it and hire someone to do it - you know - to make sure I don't hurt myself in your screw everybody but me viewpoint of the world.
 @Howard Beale  @Patches Pal Just make sure they are a licensed electrician, and properly bonded - or they will sue you for the injuries.
 @Patches Pal "Motorcycles are dangerous."
Â
Ever been on a boat with no intention of disabling yourself? Do you drive in the same traffic that drunks do? Do you go anywhere, or do anything that could be considered dangerous without intention of hurting yourself?? Why I'd bet you just look for guys on motorcycles to run down just for fun!
Â
Ride the wind, but watch for aholes in cars.
No matter who gets the cuts, they will all stand up and scream "Not me!".
 @Romey-Rome Letting em die in the street is the Republican motto.
Â
 @Andrew Bush  @Romey-Rome Actually, somewhere other than the streets - all those bodies impede their BMW's...
 @orcasthunder:Â
I was going to say it would impede their chauffered Rolls Royces & Bentleys...but hey, same difference, right?
Did you practice being callous?
Or are naturally a doooooooshnozzle?
 @spiffyjumper Doooooooshnozzle; thank you.
Â
Actually, I just noticed the coincidental play on words, but "sit down and scream" just doesn't have the same ring to it.
And whatever we do, we MUST not allow the wealthy to pay more in taxes to help provide social services. God forbid.
 @stratoonistÂ
http://www.growthstockwire.com/3150/A-Mickey-Mouse-Tax-Plan-to-Save-America
Â
http://www.growthstockwire.com/3153/A-Mickey-Mouse-Tax-Plan-to-Save-America-Part-II
 @stratoonist Thank goodness for those evil rich people!! If it wasn't for them you would have no idea how to pay for anything!!
Hopeless
 @Antistatism  @stratoonist Right. So the bank FORCES someone to take a home loan with deception and repeated high pressure tactics like those they tried on this economically educated person, but in our hypothetical here, the new 'homeowner' pays three quarters of the overinflated price before getting it repossessed. Bank has full value property and all payments made. So the overpriced home of 200k real value that they just doubled their investment on is just cool beans, huh?
Evil rich people did in fact engineer the largest ripoff in human history, with NO ONE being prosecuted to the extent of a fifteen year old kid who steals a judge's car.
Other than the likes of Warren Buffett, apparently those rich people that you speak of aren't interested in helping others...but they are okay getting rich off of others.
 @spiffyjumper LOL. Buffett. If he was sincere he could just pay his secretary in stock, or take his pay as a salary, but he doesn't.
Well we had to cut something so we can pay for the kids of illegal aliens to go to college.....remember?
 @raydawg Actually we have paid so many Millions in lawsuits and settlements from the corrupt Seattle, King County and State Police all budgets are now being effected. Â
Â
Â
@Andrew Bush:Â Â Actually, I was going to say that we have spent MILLIONS (if not BILLIONS) for settlemetns due to DSHS over SO many years - just think if that money had never needed to be paid out & could have instead be used to actually HELP those who need these sort of services?
The stupidity! It's almost always much cheaper for the state to keep someone at home rather than in a home! How is it saving money to cut that?
I am sure the SEIU will campaign vigorously to help reduce home worker labor costs because it is the right thing to do.
Seeing as how Republicans are the majority in both Houses and in the Governorship, we can rightly put the blame where it belongs...
Â
Oh, oh...
Â
I just got fact-checked!
Apparently, the Republicans are NOT in control of the entire State Governmental apparatus.
Â
I apologize for my error.
Sid,
You stop being so smart!
They don't like it.
 @Sid Vishess
 @spiffyjumper Sorry, I will try to tone it down a notch. Thanks!
Frankly, these are the sort of programs that even Fiscons would like to keep. We need to cut other nonsense to pay for it.
Yeah God forbid we cut the pork and pet projects, but let's cut services to those people that really need it, while providing services to the person popping out 20 kids and living the high life on welfare. This state and country as a whole is really, really F'd up. I don't agree with any government welfare but until somebody were to be able to step up and start a private agency to provide these services these people do need help. It's this kind of nonsense that makes me feel that government isn't the answer, because the weak and needy are screwed while the pork keeps flowing.....