Hurricane claims famous tall ship off NC coast

ELIZABETH CITY, N.C. (AP) — The final hours of the HMS Bounty were as dramatic as the Hollywood adventure films she starred in, with the crew abandoning ship in life rafts as their stately craft slowly went down in the immense waves churned up by Hurricane Sandy off the North Carolina coast.
By the time the first rescue helicopter arrived, all that was visible of the replica 18th-century sailing vessel was a strobe light atop the mighty ship's submerged masts. The roiling Atlantic Ocean had claimed the rest.
The Coast Guard rescued 14 crew members by helicopter Monday. Hours later, rescuers found one of the missing crew members, but she was unresponsive. And they were still searching for the captain.
"We pray there's no loss of life and that they rescue all of the crew," said Bill Foster, mayor of St. Petersburg, Fla., a frequent winter port for the ship and where it had been expected to arrive in November. "When a crew decides it's safer in an inflatable than it is on deck, then you know she's in peril."
The ship was originally built for the 1962 film "Mutiny on the Bounty" starring Marlon Brando, and it was featured in several other films over the years, including one of the "Pirates of the Caribbean" movies.
The vessel left Connecticut on Thursday with a crew of 11 men and five women, ranging in age from 20 to 63. Everyone aboard knew the journey could be treacherous.
"This will be a tough voyage for Bounty," read a posting on the ship's Facebook page that showed a map of its coordinates and satellite images of the storm.
The Bounty's Facebook page reads like a ship's log of her activities, with many photos of the majestic vessel plying deep blue waters and the crew working in the rigging or keeping watch on the wood-planked deck.
As Sandy's massive size became more apparent, a post on Saturday tried to soothe any worried supporters: "Rest assured that the Bounty is safe and in very capable hands. Bounty's current voyage is a calculated decision ... NOT AT ALL ... irresponsible or with a lack of foresight as some have suggested. The fact of the matter is ... A SHIP IS SAFER AT SEA THAN IN PORT!"
But as the storm gathered strength, the Facebook posts grew grimmer. By mid-morning Monday, the last update was short and ominous: "Please bear with us ... There are so many conflicting stories going on now. We are waiting for some confirmation."
Tracie Simonin, director of the HMS Bounty Organization, said the ship tried to stay clear of Sandy's power.
"It was something that we and the captain of the ship were aware of," Simonin said.
Coast Guard video of the rescue showed crew members being loaded one by one into a basket before the basket was hoisted into the helicopter.
When they returned to the mainland, some were wrapped in blankets, still wearing the blazing red survival suits they put on to stay warm in the chilly waters.
"It's one of the biggest seas I've ever been in. It was huge out there," said Coast Guard rescue swimmer Randy Haba, who helped pluck four crew members off one of the canopied life rafts and a fifth who was bobbing alone in the waves.
A helicopter pilot said the waves appeared to be 30 feet high during the rescue. The Coast Guard said in a news release that waves in many places topped out around 18 feet.
The survivors received medical attention and were to be interviewed for a Coast Guard investigation. The Coast Guard did not make them available to reporters.
The crew member who was found unresponsive, 42-year-old Claudene Christian, was taken to a hospital in Elizabeth City, where she was listed in critical condition Monday evening.
The mother of another crew member, 20-year-old Anna Sprague, said her daughter had been aboard the HMS Bounty since May.
Mary Ellen Sprague, of Savannah, Ga., said she had spoken with her daughter twice but didn't know many details because her daughter, normally talkative and outgoing, was being uncharacteristically quiet.
"She's very upset," Sprague said by telephone.
Sprague said her daughter told her the ship's diesel engines failed, and then it started taking on water.
The crew was eager to return to St. Petersburg — and to calmer waters.
"I know they were very much looking forward to being here," said Carol Everson, general manager of the pier where the vessel docks. "They were very excited about coming down."
The Bounty's captain, Robin Walbridge, was from St. Petersburg, she said.
Wallbridge learned to sail at age 10, according to his biography on the Bounty's website. Prior to the Bounty, he served as first mate on the H.M.S. Rose — the Bounty's sister ship.
A man who answered the door at a home listed as being owned by the captain and his wife said: "Not a good time," and closed the door.
Foster said the city on Florida's Gulf Coast always considered itself the ship's home.
"We're feeling a real sense of loss as a community," he said. "We grew up with the Bounty."
Foster, who was raised in St. Petersburg, remembered the ship as a family tourist attraction along the waterfront in the 1960s and 1970s. He recalled replicas of caves, a history display and pirate-themed exhibits near the Bounty. As a teenager, he attended dances on the ship.
About 10 years ago, the ship underwent a multimillion-dollar restoration.
The ship generally travels in the spring and summer. In August, large crowds greeted it when sailing into St. Augustine, Fla., Savannah, Ga., and Charleston, S.C.
___
Associated Press writers Bruce Smith in Charleston, S.C.; Tamara Lush in St. Petersburg, Fla., and Greg Schreier in Atlanta contributed to this report.
By the time the first rescue helicopter arrived, all that was visible of the replica 18th-century sailing vessel was a strobe light atop the mighty ship's submerged masts. The roiling Atlantic Ocean had claimed the rest.
The Coast Guard rescued 14 crew members by helicopter Monday. Hours later, rescuers found one of the missing crew members, but she was unresponsive. And they were still searching for the captain.
"We pray there's no loss of life and that they rescue all of the crew," said Bill Foster, mayor of St. Petersburg, Fla., a frequent winter port for the ship and where it had been expected to arrive in November. "When a crew decides it's safer in an inflatable than it is on deck, then you know she's in peril."
The ship was originally built for the 1962 film "Mutiny on the Bounty" starring Marlon Brando, and it was featured in several other films over the years, including one of the "Pirates of the Caribbean" movies.
The vessel left Connecticut on Thursday with a crew of 11 men and five women, ranging in age from 20 to 63. Everyone aboard knew the journey could be treacherous.
"This will be a tough voyage for Bounty," read a posting on the ship's Facebook page that showed a map of its coordinates and satellite images of the storm.
The Bounty's Facebook page reads like a ship's log of her activities, with many photos of the majestic vessel plying deep blue waters and the crew working in the rigging or keeping watch on the wood-planked deck.
As Sandy's massive size became more apparent, a post on Saturday tried to soothe any worried supporters: "Rest assured that the Bounty is safe and in very capable hands. Bounty's current voyage is a calculated decision ... NOT AT ALL ... irresponsible or with a lack of foresight as some have suggested. The fact of the matter is ... A SHIP IS SAFER AT SEA THAN IN PORT!"
But as the storm gathered strength, the Facebook posts grew grimmer. By mid-morning Monday, the last update was short and ominous: "Please bear with us ... There are so many conflicting stories going on now. We are waiting for some confirmation."
Tracie Simonin, director of the HMS Bounty Organization, said the ship tried to stay clear of Sandy's power.
"It was something that we and the captain of the ship were aware of," Simonin said.
Coast Guard video of the rescue showed crew members being loaded one by one into a basket before the basket was hoisted into the helicopter.
When they returned to the mainland, some were wrapped in blankets, still wearing the blazing red survival suits they put on to stay warm in the chilly waters.
"It's one of the biggest seas I've ever been in. It was huge out there," said Coast Guard rescue swimmer Randy Haba, who helped pluck four crew members off one of the canopied life rafts and a fifth who was bobbing alone in the waves.
A helicopter pilot said the waves appeared to be 30 feet high during the rescue. The Coast Guard said in a news release that waves in many places topped out around 18 feet.
The survivors received medical attention and were to be interviewed for a Coast Guard investigation. The Coast Guard did not make them available to reporters.
The crew member who was found unresponsive, 42-year-old Claudene Christian, was taken to a hospital in Elizabeth City, where she was listed in critical condition Monday evening.
The mother of another crew member, 20-year-old Anna Sprague, said her daughter had been aboard the HMS Bounty since May.
Mary Ellen Sprague, of Savannah, Ga., said she had spoken with her daughter twice but didn't know many details because her daughter, normally talkative and outgoing, was being uncharacteristically quiet.
"She's very upset," Sprague said by telephone.
Sprague said her daughter told her the ship's diesel engines failed, and then it started taking on water.
The crew was eager to return to St. Petersburg — and to calmer waters.
"I know they were very much looking forward to being here," said Carol Everson, general manager of the pier where the vessel docks. "They were very excited about coming down."
The Bounty's captain, Robin Walbridge, was from St. Petersburg, she said.
Wallbridge learned to sail at age 10, according to his biography on the Bounty's website. Prior to the Bounty, he served as first mate on the H.M.S. Rose — the Bounty's sister ship.
A man who answered the door at a home listed as being owned by the captain and his wife said: "Not a good time," and closed the door.
Foster said the city on Florida's Gulf Coast always considered itself the ship's home.
"We're feeling a real sense of loss as a community," he said. "We grew up with the Bounty."
Foster, who was raised in St. Petersburg, remembered the ship as a family tourist attraction along the waterfront in the 1960s and 1970s. He recalled replicas of caves, a history display and pirate-themed exhibits near the Bounty. As a teenager, he attended dances on the ship.
About 10 years ago, the ship underwent a multimillion-dollar restoration.
The ship generally travels in the spring and summer. In August, large crowds greeted it when sailing into St. Augustine, Fla., Savannah, Ga., and Charleston, S.C.
___
Associated Press writers Bruce Smith in Charleston, S.C.; Tamara Lush in St. Petersburg, Fla., and Greg Schreier in Atlanta contributed to this report.
A ship may be safer at sea than in port but the same can't be said for its crew.
Seems to me you want to leave a few days early to protect your ship not a few hours. Â What a shame to loose that ship. there are very few like her left in the world.
I'm an ex-Army tank crewman, so what I know about crewing a sail-powered craft in a storm can, to use the old phrase, 'be written on a matchbook with grease pencil'. That said, I'm not going to second guess the decisions or the actions by Bounty's captain or crew. To quote St. Petersburg Mayor Foster, "When a crew decides that it's safer in an inflatable than it is on deck, you she [the ship] is in peril."
I do question the basic decision to put out to sea and try to skirt the edge of a storm that experienced Coast Guard rescue personnel called a 'Franken-storm'. It is my sincere hope that when the investigation is done there wasn't a 'business decision' that killed two of the Bounty's crew.
I look back at the last Tall Ships festival in Tacoma and I'm very, very glad I had a chance to see Bounty and walk her decks. I think I speak for many of us when I say that it's a damned shame that a vessel that pretty is dead tonight.
Latest reports on another site say that one of the two missing crew members has been recovered but that she was "unresponsive" when pulled from the water and has since passed away. The last missing member is the Captain himself and since the ship apparently has gone completely down there is speculation among his crew that he went down with it.
Â
The owner of this ship is defending the actions of the captain and claims that the ship was handling the storm quite well till they lost power and therefore their ability to pump out the water from the high waves.
As a Bluewater sailor let me add my 2 cents worth. There are 2 things you can do if faced with a hurricane. If you can find a hole big enough for your ship/boat you can snug it up as tight as you can with as many lines as you can and pray that the ship/boat will still be there when the hurricane passes. If you have shallow shores you will probably lose you craft, better than losing your life. If you have a bluewater craft that is built for the open ocean you can head out to sea and position your rudder and storm jib so just slightly move, batton down your boat and go below and pray. A tall ship is a different cat all together. Because of all the surface above water you are going to take a beating no matter what you do. The only thing that will help is to take down all masts and yards and sails in a shipyard. Watch TV after the storm, I am sure they will show all the small craft that were lost or washed up on the shore.
In another line of thought, the Coast Guard Rescue Swimmers are the bravest guys I have ever met. nJumping out of the helicopter into 30' foot seas takes a special kind of bravery. If the miss the top of the wave they fall 60'. Look up the swimmers on youtube.
I have been aboard the HMS Bounty for a look-see and it is something most sailors will miss.
 @whitewings2003 I agree about the Coast Guard rescue.  Did you see the USCG video taken of the rescue on msnbc?  All I can say is yikes!  Anyone who thinks the Coast Guard is a "wussy service" should have a gander - that's really dangerous stuff anytime, esp. in the open ocean in hurricane force winds & waves.
The above storm tactic is called heaving to, google it.
Such a needless tragedy. They would've been safer staying in port than trying to sail her out to her fate. I hope they find the missing crew members alive but as of right now, I hate to say it, but they are lost at sea. Like a said such a needless tragedy.
Â
RIP HMS Bounty.
Hopefully the ship's captain and other crew member are found alive.
She was a beautiful ship. I have seen photos of Mystic CT, and it is flooding. MOST Ships have left or are leaving port.Â
I am dumbfounded....Why would you put people on a boat and go towards a hurricained? Hurricaines are not predictable and no amount of communication about the storm would have given the boat time to get out of the way. Really sad for those who are lost, I hope they are found though not likely being they are in only survival suits bouncing around in a hurricaine. Sad for the families of those lost, I hope the idiot or idiots who thought this was a good idea get sued for their stupidity, really someone should be facing wreckless endangerment charges or murder for making this decision.
This comment has been deleted
 @mhungry  @seriously? I don't have a lot of experience with tall ships, but as a retired naval officer I agree with "seriously".  Calculated or not, it was a "reckless move".  One of the first thing they taught me about ships and the weather was never cross the "T".  In layman's terms, don't cross in front of a cyclonic storm and that cyclonic storms were extremely unpredictable. Â
Â
The only way for a ship to get from Connecticut to Florida in the face of this storm was either to cross the "T", or swing out to the mid or eastern Atlantic and go around it. Â My choice, given the ship type and seakeeping ability, would have been to stay in port and get her as secure as possible and send the crew home. Â As Shakespeare said, "the better part of valor is discretion".
The pictures of that ship are breathtaking...almost nothing is as beautiful as an old, tall ship. A tragic loss; I just hope the crew members are found.
 @windtreeman Also hoping the ship isn't too damaged to be raised and rebuilt.
Can't believe they tried to outrun the storm, I imagine whoever runs this ship will be facing some lawsuits.
Taking this ship out was just plain stupid. Hope they find the missing two.
hate to see that ship lost.
Just who was it that put this national treasure in harms way. It's not like they didn't have two weeks notice that Sandy was headed their way. Tics me off.
 @lmdk2 Curious, why do you consider it a national treasure? It's only a bit over 50 years old. I'm not saying that is NOT, just...why?
Ok, who ate the strawberry's.....
I do hope they find the missing..
Â
@Mr. H Not likely, unfortunately.
This comment has been deleted
Those ships weren't made for Hurricane weather. Should have stayed in port.
Ship of fools. They never should have left port.
 @Glassman I suspect they figured that the ship would be wrecked in port, and hoped to slide down the coast before Sandy got to them. I also suspect they'll lose the ship AND two people's lives. Sad consequences for bad decisions.
 @Commenter87643 Virtually impossible to outrun a storm of this size.
 @Notyouraveragejoe  @Petwlkr  @Commenter87643 The classic definition of a superior sailor - one who used his superior judgement to avoid situations requiring the use of his superior skills.
@TheBronze yeah sail to England!
@Notyouraveragejoe @Petwlkr @Commenter87643 Agreed. A North track would have been better.
 @Petwlkr  @Commenter87643 Only because they left way too late. Sad, poor judgement has cost two lives.....