Pilot who had mental breakdown during flight to be freed
AMARILLO, Texas (AP) - A JetBlue Airways pilot who disrupted a cross-country flight by leaving the cockpit and yelling about religion and terrorists should be freed rather than committed to a mental health facility, a Texas judge ruled Friday.
Clayton Osbon was charged with interference with a flight crew for the March incident, but was found not guilty by reason of insanity in July. A forensic neuropsychologist testified in a short, unpublicized trial that Osbon had a "brief psychotic disorder" brought on by lack of sleep.
U.S. District Judge Mary Lou Robinson said Friday that Osbon would be allowed to go free, but set certain conditions for his release. He will not be allowed to fly or board any commercial or private planes without the permission of Robinson or his probation officer, and he will not be allowed to communicate with any of the passengers on the March 27 flight he disrupted, according to the judge's order.
"This is a bad situation for you and your family, but you are fortunate to have the type of immediate support that you have," Robinson said.
Passengers on the March 27 flight from New York to Las Vegas said the 49-year-old Osbon ran through the cabin yelling about Jesus and al-Qaida. The flight was diverted and safely landed in Amarillo, Texas.
At least 10 passengers have sued JetBlue over the episode.
Osbon appeared in a green jail jumpsuit and did not make an extended statement in court. His attorney, Dean Roper, said afterward that he didn't know if Osbon would fly again, but was relieved the months-long legal proceeding was at an end.
"It's been a long ordeal for everyone involved, especially Mr. Osbon," Roper said.
Osbon was expected to walk out of jail later Friday and head back to his home in Georgia. Osbon and a friend who attended Friday's hearing were planning to make the 1,300-mile trip by car, Roper said.
JetBlue Airways did not immediately respond to a phone message seeking comment.
Osbon showed up unusually late for the March 27 flight. The plane was in midair when he told his first officer that they wouldn't make it to their destination, according to court documents.
Osbon began to ramble about religion, scolded air traffic controllers to quiet down, then turned off the radios altogether and dimmed the monitors in the cockpit. He said aloud that "things just don't matter" and encouraged his co-pilot to take a leap of faith.
When he left the cockpit, passengers moved to restrain him. A flight attendant's ribs were bruised in the scuffle, but no one was seriously injured.
Neuropsychologist Robert E.H. Johnson testified in July that Osbon's psychotic disorder at the time of flight lasted for about a week afterward, according to a hearing transcript. He determined that Osbon suffered from a brief psychotic disorder and delusions "secondary to sleep deprivation." He didn't say how long Osbon had gone without sleeping before boarding the plane, and his psychiatric evaluation of Osbon has been sealed.
Those symptoms made Osbon incapable of understanding why his actions on the flight were wrong, Johnson testified.
After the July trial, Osbon was sent to a prison medical facility in North Carolina for evaluation. Robinson was to decide what happened next for Osbon in August, but instead extended his evaluation period into October after being notified that Osbon had suffered a psychotic episode in prison. She did not say what the nature of the episode was, if it was connected to his previous disorder or what prompted it.
Clayton Osbon was charged with interference with a flight crew for the March incident, but was found not guilty by reason of insanity in July. A forensic neuropsychologist testified in a short, unpublicized trial that Osbon had a "brief psychotic disorder" brought on by lack of sleep.
U.S. District Judge Mary Lou Robinson said Friday that Osbon would be allowed to go free, but set certain conditions for his release. He will not be allowed to fly or board any commercial or private planes without the permission of Robinson or his probation officer, and he will not be allowed to communicate with any of the passengers on the March 27 flight he disrupted, according to the judge's order.
"This is a bad situation for you and your family, but you are fortunate to have the type of immediate support that you have," Robinson said.
Passengers on the March 27 flight from New York to Las Vegas said the 49-year-old Osbon ran through the cabin yelling about Jesus and al-Qaida. The flight was diverted and safely landed in Amarillo, Texas.
At least 10 passengers have sued JetBlue over the episode.
Osbon appeared in a green jail jumpsuit and did not make an extended statement in court. His attorney, Dean Roper, said afterward that he didn't know if Osbon would fly again, but was relieved the months-long legal proceeding was at an end.
"It's been a long ordeal for everyone involved, especially Mr. Osbon," Roper said.
Osbon was expected to walk out of jail later Friday and head back to his home in Georgia. Osbon and a friend who attended Friday's hearing were planning to make the 1,300-mile trip by car, Roper said.
JetBlue Airways did not immediately respond to a phone message seeking comment.
Osbon showed up unusually late for the March 27 flight. The plane was in midair when he told his first officer that they wouldn't make it to their destination, according to court documents.
Osbon began to ramble about religion, scolded air traffic controllers to quiet down, then turned off the radios altogether and dimmed the monitors in the cockpit. He said aloud that "things just don't matter" and encouraged his co-pilot to take a leap of faith.
When he left the cockpit, passengers moved to restrain him. A flight attendant's ribs were bruised in the scuffle, but no one was seriously injured.
Neuropsychologist Robert E.H. Johnson testified in July that Osbon's psychotic disorder at the time of flight lasted for about a week afterward, according to a hearing transcript. He determined that Osbon suffered from a brief psychotic disorder and delusions "secondary to sleep deprivation." He didn't say how long Osbon had gone without sleeping before boarding the plane, and his psychiatric evaluation of Osbon has been sealed.
Those symptoms made Osbon incapable of understanding why his actions on the flight were wrong, Johnson testified.
After the July trial, Osbon was sent to a prison medical facility in North Carolina for evaluation. Robinson was to decide what happened next for Osbon in August, but instead extended his evaluation period into October after being notified that Osbon had suffered a psychotic episode in prison. She did not say what the nature of the episode was, if it was connected to his previous disorder or what prompted it.
The other concern I have with this decision is that it might send the wrong message to sane criminals - that they might be able to use the temporary insanity defense as a perverse kind of Get-Out-Of-Jail-Free card.
Â
"Yes, Your Honor, I did commit that terrible crime, but, you see, I was having one of those, you know, temporary psychotic thingees, and I didn't know what I was doing. But it was just temporary, and I'm over it, I'm cured, I'm just fine now, thanks for asking. Now, if you don't mind, I think I'll just be on my way ..."
Â
Maybe the rule should be that, if a guilty verdict for a crime would have resulted in 2-4 years in jail, then a not-guilty-by-reason-of-insanity verdict should result in 2-4 years in a mental institution.
I am with Central on this... Total BS,... the judge needs to hand in a letter of resignation.. This guy needs to be held accountable for what he did. Anyone else would be in jail for a while or committed for a while..or until they demonstated that they were over whatever that caused their brief disorder..
He should have to go (at his expense) to each and every passenger on that flight, and personally apologize for any and all inconvenience he caused them by scaring the heck out of them while he was having his episode..Â
Â
I strongly disagree with the judge's decision. The guy needs help and should have been committed to a mental health facility. His "brief" psychotic disorder lasted for a WEEK (which seems like a long time if it was supposedly caused by sleep deprivation), and he had another psychotic episode while under observation in prison. This is not normal. Why do we make it so difficult for people with mental illness to receive treatment? Especially when that person has demonstrated that their illness is severe enough that it results in them committing a crime!
That chair looks more comfortable than the last one I had on a flight....
I am wondering if the lack of sleep was perpetuated by the job... We have mandates for truck (big-rig, tractor trailer, semi truck) drivers for limitations on operating their vehicle. Those flight crews have it worse because they cannot slip into the on-board sleeper for those hours. They have to travel to a hotel (or whatever the air-lines have in place) and spend a few hours to settle in and then again to get ready to go. Not much time for the shut-eye. After a few months of this, anyone would crack!!
Shouldn't be allowed to board OR fly a plane, period.Â