British grandmother sentenced to death for drug smuggling

BALI, Indonesia (AP) - An Indonesian court sentenced a British grandmother to death on Tuesday for smuggling cocaine worth $2.5 million in her suitcase onto the resort island of Bali - even though prosecutors had sought only a 15-year sentence.
Lindsay June Sandiford, 56, wept when judges handed down the sentence and declined to speak to reporters on her way back to prison, covering her face with a floral scarf. She had claimed in court that she was forced to take the drugs into the country by a gang that was threatening to hurt her children.
Indonesia, like many Asian countries, is very strict on drug crimes, and most of the more than 40 foreigners on its death row were convicted of drug charges.
Sandiford's lawyer said she would appeal, a process that can take several years. Condemned criminals face a firing squad in Indonesia, which has not carried out an execution since 2008, when 10 people were put to death.
A verdict is expected in the trial of Sandiford's alleged accomplice, Briton Julian Anthony Pounder, next Tuesday. He is accused of receiving the drugs in Bali, which has a busy bar and nightclub scene where party drugs such as cocaine and Ecstasy are bought and sold between foreigners. Two other British citizens and an Indian have already been convicted and sentenced to prison in connection with the bust.
In London, British Foreign Office Minister Hugo Swire told lawmakers Wednesday that the government strongly opposes Sandiford's sentence.
"We strongly object to the death penalty and continue to provide consular assistance to Lindsay and her family during this difficult time," he said.
Martin Horwood, a member of Parliament representing Sandiford's Cheltenham constituency in western England, called the sentence a shock and said he would raise the case with Foreign Secretary William Hague.
"The days of the death penalty ought to be past. This is not the way that a country that now values democracy and human rights should really be behaving," Horwood told the BBC.
Harriet McCulloch of human rights charity Reprieve, which is assisting Sandiford, urged the British government to support her appeal.
"Lindsay has always maintained that she only agreed to carry the package to Bali after receiving threats against the lives of her family," McCulloch said. "She is clearly not a drug kingpin - she has no money to pay for a lawyer, for the travel costs of defense witnesses or even for essentials like food and water."
In its verdict, a panel of Denpasar District Court judges concluded that Sandiford had damaged the image of Bali as a tourism destination and weakened the government's drug prevention program.
"We found no reason to lighten her sentence," said Amser Simanjuntak, who headed the judicial panel.
Prosecutors had been seeking a 15-year prison sentence for Sandiford, who was arrested in May when customs officers at Bali's airport discovered 3.8 kilograms (8.4 pounds) of cocaine in the lining of her luggage.
State prosecutor Lie Putra Setiawan told reporters that the verdict was "appropriate," explaining that prosecutors had been demanding 15 years because of Sandiford's age.
Indonesia has 114 prisoners on death row, according to a March 2012 study by Australia's Lowy Institute for International Policy. Five foreigners have been executed since 1998, all for drug crimes, according to the institute.
President Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono has granted clemency to four drug offenders on death row since he took office in 2004.
The most publicized recent case internationally is that of Schapelle Corby, an Australian convicted of smuggling marijuana in 2005. Her 20-year sentence was reduced last year and she is now eligible for parole, but she remains imprisoned.
Lindsay June Sandiford, 56, wept when judges handed down the sentence and declined to speak to reporters on her way back to prison, covering her face with a floral scarf. She had claimed in court that she was forced to take the drugs into the country by a gang that was threatening to hurt her children.
Indonesia, like many Asian countries, is very strict on drug crimes, and most of the more than 40 foreigners on its death row were convicted of drug charges.
Sandiford's lawyer said she would appeal, a process that can take several years. Condemned criminals face a firing squad in Indonesia, which has not carried out an execution since 2008, when 10 people were put to death.
A verdict is expected in the trial of Sandiford's alleged accomplice, Briton Julian Anthony Pounder, next Tuesday. He is accused of receiving the drugs in Bali, which has a busy bar and nightclub scene where party drugs such as cocaine and Ecstasy are bought and sold between foreigners. Two other British citizens and an Indian have already been convicted and sentenced to prison in connection with the bust.
In London, British Foreign Office Minister Hugo Swire told lawmakers Wednesday that the government strongly opposes Sandiford's sentence.
"We strongly object to the death penalty and continue to provide consular assistance to Lindsay and her family during this difficult time," he said.
Martin Horwood, a member of Parliament representing Sandiford's Cheltenham constituency in western England, called the sentence a shock and said he would raise the case with Foreign Secretary William Hague.
"The days of the death penalty ought to be past. This is not the way that a country that now values democracy and human rights should really be behaving," Horwood told the BBC.
Harriet McCulloch of human rights charity Reprieve, which is assisting Sandiford, urged the British government to support her appeal.
"Lindsay has always maintained that she only agreed to carry the package to Bali after receiving threats against the lives of her family," McCulloch said. "She is clearly not a drug kingpin - she has no money to pay for a lawyer, for the travel costs of defense witnesses or even for essentials like food and water."
In its verdict, a panel of Denpasar District Court judges concluded that Sandiford had damaged the image of Bali as a tourism destination and weakened the government's drug prevention program.
"We found no reason to lighten her sentence," said Amser Simanjuntak, who headed the judicial panel.
Prosecutors had been seeking a 15-year prison sentence for Sandiford, who was arrested in May when customs officers at Bali's airport discovered 3.8 kilograms (8.4 pounds) of cocaine in the lining of her luggage.
State prosecutor Lie Putra Setiawan told reporters that the verdict was "appropriate," explaining that prosecutors had been demanding 15 years because of Sandiford's age.
Indonesia has 114 prisoners on death row, according to a March 2012 study by Australia's Lowy Institute for International Policy. Five foreigners have been executed since 1998, all for drug crimes, according to the institute.
President Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono has granted clemency to four drug offenders on death row since he took office in 2004.
The most publicized recent case internationally is that of Schapelle Corby, an Australian convicted of smuggling marijuana in 2005. Her 20-year sentence was reduced last year and she is now eligible for parole, but she remains imprisoned.
"President Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono has granted clemency to four drug offenders on death row since he took office in 2004." Well here is one obvious reason for this senseless ruling  Hes been in office for 9 years now? Hes' no president. This is a Dictator, and with all dictators come corruption. and this by definition makes this not of a Democracy.
How does smuggling drugs warrant the Death Penalty????????? I don;t get it!!
Are they stupid??? A murder will get 25 to life with parole and a drug smuggler will get death??
I don't get it!!
A stalker that threatens some one or rapes some one will get 60 years in jail with no parole, but a drug smuggler get's the death sentence??
I don;t get it!!
We humane are absolutely idiotic dummy's!
That I get!
 @reelin21 Watch the show "First 48: and you begin to realize that about 80% of the homicides investigated on the program are drug related. I feel sorry for the grandmother here as she was likely corherced into doing what she did but I can understand the Indonesian governments view on the problem.If we shot on site all of the Zetos gang members caught trying to smuggle crap into our country would it not put a dent in our problem?
Wha? She never saw the movie Midnight Express?
 @jkdrummerÂ
Midnight Express kept me from buying pot outside the 7-11 for most of  my teenage years... Â
@jkdrummer Now I have that theme song stuck in my head....
 @jkdrummer That was my first thought! I've seen that movie dozens of times over the years, and that airport scene still scares the crap out of me each time.Â
And who was hurt by her activity except those who choose to buy the stuff. Â This wasn't force fed to little children for goodness sakes. Â The death penalty? Â If I had the money, I'd hire mercenaries to go get her. Â Shameful penalty.
Those 8.4 lbs of cocaine could destroy the lives of quite a few people, possibly even end some lives. Â Death for dealing death is quite appropriate. Â
 @Opus8no5 Agreed.  But who will go after the biggest drug dealers.  I just can't get out of my head some details about our own CIA running plane-loads of the stuff.  And I hear that the poppies are growing more that ever since we brought 'democracy' to Afghanistan.
Holy crap! The death sentence for a small time drug smuggling case?! WTF is wrong with that country? Did they even investigate the claims that this woman was threatened into committing this crime? I mean, I'm not stupid, I know that some people will say anything to cover their own butts, but could it actually be possible that she was threatened?
Â
If the prosecutors only asked for a 15 year sentence why did the judicial panel opt for the death penalty?
Â
Also, as stated in the article, "Denpasar District Court judges concluded that Sandiford had damaged the image of Bali as a tourism destination." The fact that they chose to give this woman the death penalty is more of a deterrent to visiting that country than the fact that the woman tried to smuggle in drugs!
Â
Â
 @Tattooed_Angel 2.5 mil is not exactly small potatoes.  Singapore is worse, automatic death penalty for dugs,  - and that is a deterrent in many cases.
@Doxie Your right, I don't think it is small potatoes but 8 pounds shouldn't equal her life. It's not like she some big time drug ring leader or something.
 @Tattooed_Angel  @Doxie Well, that's the way they roll there, she should have watched a few episodes of Locked Up Abroad before agreeing!
In the eyes of a foreign country, how many deaths or lives would have been destroyed as a result of the drugs that were brought into the county if she had gotten away with it? Perhaps they have tough laws because the death/inprisonment of one person for breaking the law is a fair replacement for the many lives that might have been saved. I'm not saying she is guilty or innocent, or if the punishment is fair or not. I think of the pain those drugs would have caused. I'm glad they caught her. And in my opinion, just because she's a grandmother has nothing to do with this story. Many criminals have children or grandchildren, but it is not mentioned when they commit a crime.
If she has no money it makes me wonder if there could be some truth is what she is saying. I hope they seriously investigate this before handing down any punishment. That being said, the death penalty seems pretty harsh. I know I won't ever being going over to that part of the world. Even though I don't smuggle drugs, I'd be afraid of breaking some law I don't know about and then who knows what will happen.
A death sentence for a drug violation is draconian. I won't be taking my vacation dollars to a place that would do that. For someone that's not wealthy, I can have a lavish vacation at a US destination for what I would save on airfare, and support American jobs in the process. Going to some club and snorting a bunch of coke isn't high on my list of vacation activities. Doesn't anyone know how to play Canasta anymore? Sheesh.Â
 @Insomniac Dreams I do, Canasta is awesome!  But so is Asia.......very cheap and beauty/culture aplenty, no problem at all if you live within the laws there. Â
@Insomniac Dreams Oooh! I just learned how to play Canasta on New Years Eve (we stayed up playing it until 6am). What a fun game! Nobody likes to sit around and play card games anymore. It's a shame.
@Insomniac Dreams - WOW - Canasta? You are seriously dating yourself there...  ;)  I got a big laugh on that one as yes, I used to know how to play it but haven't played it in a very long time. My parents used to play it, so I joined in with those house games.
Wow. Pretty uppity for a British Parlimentarian to imply that the Indonesians are 'uncivilized and don't value democracy' for simply upholding their laws. This woman was warned when she debarked that drug smuggling is a death penalty offense and she knew that Indonesia had executed people for it in the past.
Â
Now what will probably happen is that there'll be some diplomatic chair polishing and a few headlines and the woman will be extridited and put on a persona non grata list, but she was fully warned about this.
funny
Honestly if you get threats against your family you go to the authorities | before which you tell your family members and pull them together - the second you give in to one threat there will be another and another... if her story is true it is a real shame she did not do the smarter thing and goto the cops
 @Freespeech Well, the second you let one drug-mule granny off the hook because she says "they had her family", they'll all start saying it....
She should thank her lucky stars she is not in Singapore. Â Her sentence would be carried out swiftly (hanging by the neck) and Indonesia has not executed since 2008. Â I don't have much sympathy; boggles the mind how many people think 'they' will be the ones to get away with it. Â I go all over and fear nothing because the only thing I 'smuggle' is Fiber One Bars!
@Doxie - Are those Fiber One Bars good? ;)  I would love to have the $$ and the time to go to Singapore. Years ago, I had seen a cruise that did several Asian countries for 3 weeks and I had the money then but not the time off available work! LOL...
 @Elaine2  @Doxie Yes, Fiber One makes good stuff.  Get them at Costco if you can, about $10 for dozens versus $5 for 8 at the store.  Singapore is very, very sanitized.  Very clean, very appearance-conscious, very wealthy, very safe.  Tokyo is similar but has a different vibe.  I actually prefer Thailand, I enjoy the 'rustic' elements to other countries!  But if you like shopping, eating, gambling in a VERY clean and air conditioned environment, with no fear of being panhandled, hustled to buy something, run over by a tuk tuk, getting food poisoning, Singapore's your place.  I hope you get on that cruise someday.
 @MargeGunderson  @Elaine2 China is the same way - and they don't give you napkins!  So you will be sitting there, sweating bullets, slobbering, coughing, and nothing to wipe with.  You have to really like spicy, you like a lot, LOL!  Thanks and I hope you get there someday.  It's nice to have a nice room, but the real fun is in the nitty-gritty of places where people really live their lives, not in the hotel.  My husband is very cautious (and working) so it freaks him out to get a text that I just ate noodles and donuts on the street - I get one back saying, "Stop, or you shall surely die!"  But anything that could kill you would be decimated by the spices and boiling water. Â
 @Doxie  @Elaine2 Thanks for the insight! :D  I remember when I first ordered Thai takeout here many years ago. Gentleman who took my order was friendly and chatting as we waited for my food.
Same conversational tone, he asks/says, "You like spicy?" Â I agree, thinking he was just talking about my dinner choice. He says, "You really like spicy, you like a lot?"Â
Still thinking we're just chatting, I agree again. Got home and that stuff was soooo flaming hot! Very tasty, but hellfire hot. Ended up making a lot more rice than what came with it, and even a tiny bite cut with a big bite of rice was still almost unbearably hot.Â
Now I not only tell how many stars, but I check what scale we're talking â in Thai-speak, three of three stars is a lot different ballgame than three of five stars... :D
Â
Hope you have a blast on your trip, with great company and great food.Â
 @Doxie - Thanks!  I sure hope I can travel like that again sometime.  I had a dream of a very fancy hotel in some tropical climate when I was a kid - had that dream for years and then later on, my Mom got a coffee table book called Grand Hotels of the World or something like that... and I was astonished to find a picture spread of my dream hotel in Singapore.  I often wonder if it had been in movies or something, as I had seen everything in there, down to the red carpet and the whole thing, little details.  My Mom thought I was destined to go there in my life.  It sounds really great. Â
 @MargeGunderson  @Elaine2 Don't be so sure!  Their food is different than what we eat here and they don't ask how many stars you want - they just give 12-15 stars worth of heat!  Some food looks strange(piles of brown 'worms') but they do have great fruits and you know what they cook right on the sidewalk in Bangkok?  Donuts!  It's a wonderful place and the people are really gracious and gentle.  It's hotter than a fritter though.  I hope you go someday.
 @Doxie  @Elaine2 If I stayed in Thailand for a week or so, I'd probably be detained on suspicion of smuggling because I would weigh about 40 additional pounds on the return trip from all of that wonderful food! :DÂ
Â
 @Doxie I find that people who think of Singapore, Malyasia, or Indonesia as "backwards, 3d-world nations" are completely uneducated about the region and spew off ignorant remarks based on their Euroccentric attitudes.Â
Â
Historically, the nation of Great Britain remains the biggest drug dealer in Asia and possibly the world... read about the Opium War.Â
@MyTacoma @Doxie I really enjoyed my time in all of those countries. They are a beautiful people and country.
 @MyTacoma Yes, I am aware of the Brits' drug smuggling.  I watched a few "Locked Up Abroad" episodes and just shake my head.  I'm going to Singapore in a few weeks and their disembarkation card states clearly that drugs = death.  Even if someone has keys to a place where drugs were found, they can be presumed to have had a part in it and be put to death! Â
Wow. That is harsh. I don't support people breaking laws, or smuggling drugs. Drugs kill a lot of people, along with the violence that accompanies the drug trade.  However, a death penalty by firing squad?  What century is this?  The last firing squad masacre of 10 people was only 4 years ago, and the majority of people on death row are foreigners held on drug  charges.  That's pretty harsh when the prosecutor asks for 15 years and the Court goes rogue and calls for her death.  I would hope that people start getting a clue about Bali and Indonesia, and stop spending money to visit there.  I would never go there. Even for someone who does not do drugs at all, the risk of being arrested erroneously, seems way too possible in a place like that.  Let's see if the British Govt has any guts...  or if they'll let this ridiculous sentence stand.  (and when they said "grandmother" and "because of her age" I kept thinking she was like 70, but 56? that's young.)  Not sure about her story, but it does seem possible considering a woman who has no resources took a trip to Bali?  Who paid for the trip?  Or did she agree to do it because she had no money? Â
 @DT Texas alone has executed nearly 80 people since 2008. I'm sure that Texas' executions were over murder, not drug dealing, but then how many of those murders were drug related? A fair number, I bet. Perhaps Indonesia has a better handle on the problem.
Â
As for the manner of execution, if the death penalty is supposed to serve as a deterrent to crime, then something violent like a firing squad should be more effective than a nice, civilized lethal injection.
 @DT Not going because you don't feel safe (regardless of the nature of the threat) absolutely makes sense, of course. But boycotting businesses because of decisions over which they have no control is hurting the wrong people.Â
Â
You would understandably be pretty upset if everyone starting calling for total boycotts of your place of employment because your city council voted for something that upset the masses.Â
@DT - 56 and a grandmother - really within the possibilities. I have a friend who was a grandmother at 34. You start young and they start young and there you go. ;)
@DT Well let's all cancel our travel plans because you don't think it's fair.
There is a simple soloution to all this. If you don't want to be put to beath in Bali, don't try and smuggle in 8 pounds of cocaine.
 @Surveyor1  @DT What, are you suggesting following the laws or something?
Respecting the country that graciously allows us to visit, by not smuggling in millions of dollars worth of an addictive poison that destroys the lives of their citizens?
Â
Man, where do you get such crazy thinking? Â
@DT don't like the countries rules? don't break their laws. I have actualy been to Bali, Singapore and loved it? So, you are judging them on how they treat drug smugglers instead of the actual country? Seems pretty shallow of you, don't you think? Also, Bali is a resort destination for the Australians, so they are well aware of what the rules are. In singapore they tell you what to expect if you break their laws. I just wish that this country could do the same thing about our criminals.
 @DT The chances of getting arrested and executed erroneously is extremely slim. The punish doesn't really fit the crime, but it is their law and visitors are reminded continually reminded not to bring in drugs.Â
Â
Â
her story is not entirely unbelievable.. They would have to find the guys that gave her the "package".
Another ridiculous country with ridiculous civil rights violations. Don't know why people even go to some of these backward countries that have never even heard the phrase inalienable rights.
@Blindman So you are implying that we all have an inalienable right to smuggle drugs into other countries and not face said country's laws against smuggling? Seems kinda silly to me.
@Blindman me thinks you are talking out of your azz again.
 @Blindman Not sure where you're going with this. We have an inalienable right to smuggle illicit drugs into another country? It's not like they are falsely accusing her. She has admitted to the crime.
 @Blindman Civil rights violation by our standards. Countries like Indonesia and Malaysia deal with drug smuggling pretty harshly. Much of their judicial codes were established by the Dutch and English colonial masters, and amended to fit their Islamic laws. A lot of Europeans, Australians, and Americans vacation there beacause of the warm climate and beautiful environment.
If you don't want to deal with the penalties, don't try to pee in someone else's pool.
@what? they tell you what will happen if you break the laws in their countries.