Penn St fined $60 million, wins vacated from '98-11
»Play Video
INDIANAPOLIS (AP) - Penn State football was all but dismantled Monday by an NCAA ruling that wiped away 14 years of coach Joe Paterno's victories and imposed a mountain of fines and penalties, crippling a program whose pedophile assistant coach spent years molesting children, sometimes on school property.
The sanctions by the governing body of college sports also imposed unprecedented fines of $60 million, ordered Penn State to sit out the postseason for four years, capped scholarships at 20 below the normal limit for four years and placed football on five years' probation.
Current or incoming football players are free to immediately transfer and compete at another school.
The NCAA's sanctions following the worst scandal in the history of college football stopped short of delivering the "death penalty" - shutting down the sport completely. It actually did everything but kill it.
"The sanctions needed to reflect our goals of providing cultural change," NCAA President Mark Emmert said as he announced the penalties at a news conference in Indianapolis.
The NCAA ruling holds the university accountable for the failure of those in power to protect children and insists that all areas of the university community are held to the same high standards of honesty and integrity.
"Against this backdrop, Penn State accepts the penalties and corrective actions announced today by the NCAA," Penn State President Rodney Erickson said in a statement. "With today's announcement and the action it requires of us, the University takes a significant step forward."
The Big Ten announced that Penn State would not be allowed to share in the conference's bowl revenue during the NCAA's postseason ban, an estimated loss of about $13 million. And the NCAA reserved the right to add additional penalties.
Jerry Sandusky, a former Penn State defensive coordinator, was found guilty in June of sexually abusing young boys, sometimes on campus. An investigation commissioned by the school and released July 12 found that Paterno, who died in January, and several other top officials at Penn State stayed quiet for years about accusations against Sandusky.
Emmert fast-tracked penalties rather than go through the usual circuitous series of investigations and hearings. The NCAA said the $60 million is equivalent to the annual gross revenue of the football program. The money must be paid into an endowment for external programs preventing child sexual abuse or assisting victims and may not be used to fund such programs at Penn State.
"Football will never again be placed ahead of educating, nurturing and protecting young people," Emmert said.
By vacating 112 Penn State victories from 1998-2011, the sanctions cost Paterno 111 wins. Former Florida State coach Bobby Bowden will now hold the top spot in the NCAA record book with 377 major-college wins. Paterno, who was fired days after Sandusky was charged, will be credited with 298 wins. Vacated wins are not the same as forfeits - they don't count as losses or wins for either school.
The scholarship reductions mean Penn State's roster will be capped at 65 scholarship players beginning in 2014. The normal scholarship limit for major college football programs is 85. Playing with 20 less is devastating to a program that tries to compete at the highest level of the sport.
In comparison, the harsh NCAA sanctions placed upon USC several years ago left the Trojans with only 75 scholarships per year over a three-year period.
The postseason ban is the longest handed out by the NCAA since it gave a four-year ban to Indiana football in 1960.
Bill O'Brien, who was hired to replace Paterno, now faces the daunting task of building future teams with severe limitations, and trying to keep current players from fleeing to other schools. Star players such as tailback Silas Redd and linebacker Gerald Hodges are now essentially free agents.
"I knew when I accepted the position that there would be tough times ahead," O'Brien said. "But I am committed for the long term to Penn State and our student athletes."
Big Ten Commissioner Jim Delany said that players will likely be allowed to transfer within the conference, something that is usually restricted. The possible exodus isn't confined to just the next few months. Penn State players currently on the roster are free to transfer without restrictions for the length of their careers.
Penn State players left a team meeting on campus in State College, Pa., without talking to reporters. Penn State's season starts Sept. 1 at home against Ohio University.
The sanctions came a day after the school took down a statue of Paterno that stood outside Beaver Stadium and was a rallying point for the coaches' supporters throughout the scandal.
At a student union on campus, several dozen alumni and students gasped, groaned and whistled as they watched Emmert's news conference.
"It was kind of just like a head shaker," said Matt Bray, an 18-year-old freshman from West Chester, Pa. "You knew it was coming, but it was hard to hear."
Emmert had earlier said he had "never seen anything as egregious" as the horrific crimes of Sandusky and the cover-up by Paterno and others at the university, including former Penn State President Graham Spanier and athletic director Tim Curley.
The Penn State investigation headed by former FBI Director Louis Freeh said school officials kept what they knew from police and other authorities for years, enabling the abuse to go on.
There had been calls across the nation for Penn State to receive the "death penalty," and Emmert had not ruled out that possibility as late as last week - though Penn State did not fit the criteria for it. That punishment is for teams that commit a major violation while already being sanctioned.
"This case is obviously incredibly unprecedented in every aspect of it," Emmert said, "as are these actions that we're taking today."
Penn State football under Paterno was built on - and thrived upon - the premise that it did things the right way. That it was not a football factory where only wins and losses determined success. Every major college football program tries to send that message, but Penn State built its brand on it.
Paterno's "Grand Experiment" was about winning with integrity, graduating players and sending men into the world ready to succeed in life, not just football. But he still won a lot - a record-setting 409 victories.
The NCAA had never sanctioned, or seriously investigated Penn State. Few, if any, national powers could make that claim.
Southern California, Ohio State, Alabama, all have run afoul of the NCAA. Even Notre Dame went on probation for two years after a booster lavished gifts on players in the 1990s.
The harshest penalty handed down to a football program came in the '80s, when the NCAA shut down SMU's team for a year. SMU football has never gotten back to the level of success it had before the "death penalty."
Emmert said there were concerns about the collateral damage of shutting down Penn State football for a year, and that's why the death penalty was ruled out.
"It hurts people who had absolutely nothing to do with this process, which is always the case," he said.
Emmert added that no attempt was made for the sanctions to be more severe than the death penalty.
"That isn't a comparison I or anyone else needs to make," he said. "People in the media can make those comparisons."
Delany said he believes Penn State is capable of bouncing back from the sanctions.
"I do have a strong sense that many of the ingredients of success are still at Penn State and will be there in future years," he said.
The sanctions by the governing body of college sports also imposed unprecedented fines of $60 million, ordered Penn State to sit out the postseason for four years, capped scholarships at 20 below the normal limit for four years and placed football on five years' probation.
Current or incoming football players are free to immediately transfer and compete at another school.
The NCAA's sanctions following the worst scandal in the history of college football stopped short of delivering the "death penalty" - shutting down the sport completely. It actually did everything but kill it.
"The sanctions needed to reflect our goals of providing cultural change," NCAA President Mark Emmert said as he announced the penalties at a news conference in Indianapolis.
The NCAA ruling holds the university accountable for the failure of those in power to protect children and insists that all areas of the university community are held to the same high standards of honesty and integrity.
"Against this backdrop, Penn State accepts the penalties and corrective actions announced today by the NCAA," Penn State President Rodney Erickson said in a statement. "With today's announcement and the action it requires of us, the University takes a significant step forward."
The Big Ten announced that Penn State would not be allowed to share in the conference's bowl revenue during the NCAA's postseason ban, an estimated loss of about $13 million. And the NCAA reserved the right to add additional penalties.
Jerry Sandusky, a former Penn State defensive coordinator, was found guilty in June of sexually abusing young boys, sometimes on campus. An investigation commissioned by the school and released July 12 found that Paterno, who died in January, and several other top officials at Penn State stayed quiet for years about accusations against Sandusky.
Emmert fast-tracked penalties rather than go through the usual circuitous series of investigations and hearings. The NCAA said the $60 million is equivalent to the annual gross revenue of the football program. The money must be paid into an endowment for external programs preventing child sexual abuse or assisting victims and may not be used to fund such programs at Penn State.
"Football will never again be placed ahead of educating, nurturing and protecting young people," Emmert said.
By vacating 112 Penn State victories from 1998-2011, the sanctions cost Paterno 111 wins. Former Florida State coach Bobby Bowden will now hold the top spot in the NCAA record book with 377 major-college wins. Paterno, who was fired days after Sandusky was charged, will be credited with 298 wins. Vacated wins are not the same as forfeits - they don't count as losses or wins for either school.
The scholarship reductions mean Penn State's roster will be capped at 65 scholarship players beginning in 2014. The normal scholarship limit for major college football programs is 85. Playing with 20 less is devastating to a program that tries to compete at the highest level of the sport.
In comparison, the harsh NCAA sanctions placed upon USC several years ago left the Trojans with only 75 scholarships per year over a three-year period.
The postseason ban is the longest handed out by the NCAA since it gave a four-year ban to Indiana football in 1960.
Bill O'Brien, who was hired to replace Paterno, now faces the daunting task of building future teams with severe limitations, and trying to keep current players from fleeing to other schools. Star players such as tailback Silas Redd and linebacker Gerald Hodges are now essentially free agents.
"I knew when I accepted the position that there would be tough times ahead," O'Brien said. "But I am committed for the long term to Penn State and our student athletes."
Big Ten Commissioner Jim Delany said that players will likely be allowed to transfer within the conference, something that is usually restricted. The possible exodus isn't confined to just the next few months. Penn State players currently on the roster are free to transfer without restrictions for the length of their careers.
Penn State players left a team meeting on campus in State College, Pa., without talking to reporters. Penn State's season starts Sept. 1 at home against Ohio University.
The sanctions came a day after the school took down a statue of Paterno that stood outside Beaver Stadium and was a rallying point for the coaches' supporters throughout the scandal.
At a student union on campus, several dozen alumni and students gasped, groaned and whistled as they watched Emmert's news conference.
"It was kind of just like a head shaker," said Matt Bray, an 18-year-old freshman from West Chester, Pa. "You knew it was coming, but it was hard to hear."
Emmert had earlier said he had "never seen anything as egregious" as the horrific crimes of Sandusky and the cover-up by Paterno and others at the university, including former Penn State President Graham Spanier and athletic director Tim Curley.
The Penn State investigation headed by former FBI Director Louis Freeh said school officials kept what they knew from police and other authorities for years, enabling the abuse to go on.
There had been calls across the nation for Penn State to receive the "death penalty," and Emmert had not ruled out that possibility as late as last week - though Penn State did not fit the criteria for it. That punishment is for teams that commit a major violation while already being sanctioned.
"This case is obviously incredibly unprecedented in every aspect of it," Emmert said, "as are these actions that we're taking today."
Penn State football under Paterno was built on - and thrived upon - the premise that it did things the right way. That it was not a football factory where only wins and losses determined success. Every major college football program tries to send that message, but Penn State built its brand on it.
Paterno's "Grand Experiment" was about winning with integrity, graduating players and sending men into the world ready to succeed in life, not just football. But he still won a lot - a record-setting 409 victories.
The NCAA had never sanctioned, or seriously investigated Penn State. Few, if any, national powers could make that claim.
Southern California, Ohio State, Alabama, all have run afoul of the NCAA. Even Notre Dame went on probation for two years after a booster lavished gifts on players in the 1990s.
The harshest penalty handed down to a football program came in the '80s, when the NCAA shut down SMU's team for a year. SMU football has never gotten back to the level of success it had before the "death penalty."
Emmert said there were concerns about the collateral damage of shutting down Penn State football for a year, and that's why the death penalty was ruled out.
"It hurts people who had absolutely nothing to do with this process, which is always the case," he said.
Emmert added that no attempt was made for the sanctions to be more severe than the death penalty.
"That isn't a comparison I or anyone else needs to make," he said. "People in the media can make those comparisons."
Delany said he believes Penn State is capable of bouncing back from the sanctions.
"I do have a strong sense that many of the ingredients of success are still at Penn State and will be there in future years," he said.
To all of you who thinks it's a shame that players and others will suffer because of a few, I suppose that's true. But a line needs to be drawn. Winning should not be put above the lives of children and let it be a lesson for others to clean their house before they get caught.Â
So Penn State was involved in a cover-up, eh?  Isn't Michael Mann at PSU now?Â
Yeah there you go. Let's play God and change history by saying these wins and these efforts by the students and players who got that far didn't happen. Not to mention punishing them for something they had nothing to do with and punish them in the future for something they still had nothing to do with. Smart thinking you guys! I tell ya, I feel so very damn sorry for all of those students there, past and present, or even future! Use them as an example for something they didn't contribute to!
@Zoso I thought about that also but then.....any student or student athlete during the time these sick actions were taking place has already derived their benefits from the University (if they worked and earned their degree and maybe even a job) it doesn't get much better than that....Athletes (the best ones) have already made the pros and will likely not lose their job due to this either so who has the NCAA action hurt? The students there now? NO! they should focus on the fortune they have that allows them to attend a University in pursuit of a degree so they are not as hurt as they think (The advice I would give my child is "Enough about it, get to your studies, you are not there for football") The scholarship athletes? They will have to work harder to make a squad on scholarship or work hard to make grades for financial aid but I think this only hurts two kinds of people... the 3rd season "General Studies" athlete that possess more sport talent than school aptitude and is taking a slot from a genuine student and the Paterno cult who lives and dies by the scoreboard...WHo is hurt really? ...exactly who the NCAA wanted to hurt .......just my opinionÂ
 @schramalot Yeah I was just realizing that about the past students. Obviously they'd be fine and sucessful with whatever they're doing now, so I guess that much really shouldn't matter.
This comment has been deleted
 @kybhotbs I doubt it, it would take a complete moron to confuse the push to curtail anti-gay rhetoric with protecting pedophiles. Any person with any kind of awareness knows the two are completely different and unrelated items. The official reports say it all, Penn State put football ahead of everything and didn't do the right thing.Â
 @kennewickman "it would take a complete moron to confuse the push to curtail anti-gay rhetoric with protecting pedophiles."
Unfortunately, as we see far too often on this forum, there are still a lot of morons infesting our society...
Â
Â
@kybhotbs Dude, you have issues. The only one seeing a 700 lb gorilla is you, the "tyrannical PC environment" exists only in your fractured mind. This has nothing to do with homosexuality just as some sick animal molesting a little girl has nothing to with heterosexuality. Try and get with the program, okay?
 @kybhotbs  @OrcasThunder  @kennewickman What you seem to not comprehend is that there is no link between homosexuality and pedophilia.
Homosexuality is about love of someone of the same gender.
Pedophilia is about an adult forcing their imagined power on children - it has nothing to do with"love"...or even "sex". There are pedophile fathers who abuse their daughters, pedophile mothers who abuse their sons. It is simply and only about exerting control and fear over the child.to satisfy the adult's twisted needs.
Â
Â
 @kybhotbs  @OrcasThunder  @kennewickman My fault - for insulting morons...
 @kybhotbs Even if the environment did contribute, and even if it would have been different if girls had been the victims, that does not in any way excuse a cover-up. Not even a teeny tiny bit.Â
So to go after the people that tried to cover this up they are going to punish the students of the school. Â Sounds like the NCAA are running sports about the same way the politicians are running this country. Â Let the people on top get away with it and punish the working class. Â How about leaving the football team alone and just replacing the administration of the school. Â After all it was the people in charge that tried to cover it up. Â Not the students that need the scholarships.
I hope we have all learned a lesson here.Â
 @Gale Davis-Simpson The other lesson is other schools are going to work much much harder at keeping their wrongdoings under wraps and out of the media.Â
This comment has been deleted
 @newdragon That doesn't make sense. The current students are not the victims of the sex abuse. If there are any, that would be a different story for each individual. Instead, the money is going to be placed into an endowment to for sex abuse prevention measures and to assist sex abuse victims. I don't see why the students should suddenly get free tuition in that they were not victims of abuse.Â
 @newdragon I agree with you, but I'd guess that figure was derived by what they took in from the FB program since '98. Bowl games, attendance and coaching endorsements.
The article says that $60 million is equivalent to the annual gross revenues of the FB program. One year, not fourteen..
I'm not condoning the role Paterno may have played in this, but to vacate the wins from all those years that affect not only every player that contributed to that and may have built a legacy on that but also the whole university in general, isn't that a little extreme?
I thought it was more extreme to minimize on-going molestation in favor of playing football. Sandusky was kept on because he was great defensive coach and winning football games that took precedence over allegations, eye witness testimony, and internal investigations about child molestation. Comparison of extreme should be scrutinized here.
I think Paterno should have taken a lesson from what most parents should be teaching their kids. If something bad is happening, go tell an adult. If they don't listen, go tell another and keep yelling louder until someone will listen.
The old addage of Pay Me Now or Pay Me Later.
Â
I would love to be able to go back in time to see what would have happened had the school's "leadership" taken the proper steps. This is a sick legacy for what was once a proud program.
Â
Moral of the story "Don't try to decieve, you'll eventually get caught". Whether you're a swindler like Bernie Madoff, Tony Rezko, a sick perverted child molester, or the head of a college, things will catch up with you.
I do not sanction in any way the horrific abuse that happened at Penn State - and clearly the "don't ask, don't tell" policies there needed to change. But...Sandusky is in jail, Paterno's dead and the other top officials will be appropriately dealt with. I am sad for the players who believed they were in a program with integrity, willing to work hard to succeed and have now had both their sport, and their legacy taken away from them. You still won the games, guys - nobody can take that away from you no matter what the record says.
@Kantian If I was a player for Penn State during the time period I wouldn't want to be connected to it anymore. Yeah, it sucks for the players but what about all of the kids that had everything taken from them because of the pedophile and his protectors? A message needs to be sent to other schools that this kind of stuff won't fly.
What a tangled web we weave, when we first practice to deceive. What on earth made those administrators think they could get away with the coverup indefinitely. Why didn't they stop to think that dealing with this immediately and harshly would be far better than the consequences of keeping it under wraps? Well, now they know those consequences and I hope every college in the country takes note.
I got some Penn State football tickets, really cheap.
I feel that what happened to the children was completely wrong but I don't think they should be doing this to the football program period. Fire the coaches who cares. You just lost 80 opportunities for a kid to go to school who probably couldn't with today's rates for tuition! Do they deserve that? I literally do not see the justification of this punishment fit for this crime. I feel like this is a more harsh punishment than they would have gotten for cheating for the last 4 years or something. Why didn't these victims go to the police in the first place and even if they did accuse Sandusky of doing this, why would they be telling Paterno about it? What can he do, other than defend one of his colleague  and friend he had for years?Â
There are lots of reasonable comments on here.Â
Â
In my opinion, they still should have gotten the complete ax, no more football. Even with sanctions, they can recover.
Â
What about the victims though - can they recover? Time will tell, but my thought is that most won't. This will haunt them, as it should anyone associated with football at Penn St.
 @commonHuskyfan I understand what you're saying, but that course would impact a lot of people who really didn't know. Players, ticket takers, lawn crews, other coaches and anyone else hired in to work related to FB there.
I think this is a better decision than the "death penalty" because the team going forward will be impacted but mainly the penalty falls on Paterno's record. He loses credit for his legacy and that is just. The new coach has a great opportunity to shine by doing his job well and bringing the team up from the lowest level of shame.
 @SoTweetie And to the new coach's credit he supports this - in spite of the report that a large portion of his salary package rests on his leading the teams to bowl games...so it will personally cost him a significant amount of money.
Hopefully this will set the foundation for a sea change in the attitude that puts sport records above what should have been a matter of common sense and humanity when face with a moral question of this magnitude. This should have been a no-brainer - report and let the authorities handle it.
Â
EVERY organization that deals with children, or even just with those who do work with kids, needs to take this message and make it the first rule of management.
I was a strong advocate that the program should be terminated and excised from the history books.But on further reflection, I agree with this. Better to leave the program up to be a shell of its former self than to make it an outright martyr.Do I feel bad for those who are harmed by this who didn't have a hand in it: I do. But we're not dealing with the acts of a single person. We're talking about an institution whose highest representatives enabled ongoing rape of children through their inaction. The institution must pay a price as well as the individuals.In the long-run though, does anyone think that this won't hurt everyone associated with this school? "Penn State" is now synonymous with "child rape". Do you want to go into an interview with that on your resume? Would you want to present before your scientific peers your latest research and declare that you work at "Child Rape U"?Fair, no. But what happened to those kids wasn't fair.In closing, I hope they melt down that statue and turn it into a memorial for all victims of child rape (preferably by the same artist). That is a fitting use for that statue.Â
 @Julian Arancia Beyond the facts of this as an abject failure of the leadership, every organization in this country needs to understand that protecting the school, the company, the bank, the club or even just the record of achievements simply does not outweigh doing the right thing - and that not doing that can and will harm those who had no part in the moral failures perhaps even more than the price paid by those who did commit the mistakes.
Â
It is a principle that SHOULD be applied in every business that puts profits and bonuses head of what the action might do to the people, the country, and the economy...and yet how many CEO's have been sent to the Big House, how many bank/corporate gamblers have seen their salaries drop and the bonuses recalled even now, when those too big to fail banks fail to follow the law and logic in the search for more ways to get richer at the cost of the little guy? Sure, some of the "traders" have been fired and may even have their "earnings" taken back...but what of the people who have a different translation than Harry did to "the buck stops here!"?
Â
If Penn State were a private school, would the powers running it have even been admonished?
What a shame to punish the players for what the administration did. It ust does not seem right that the players have to pay for the stupid mistakes the school did. By letting them go somewhere else to play with no penalties is not right either. It just means that some other player from another school will not get a scholarship that deserves one.and not play football.
@egle... Maybe not, remember Div 1A schools cap at 65 full rides and Lord knows how many walk ons....(seriously it seems different for every school). I think if a player is good AND has the grades they can find a place should they want to xfer....
 @egle But you can't have it both ways. To punish the program, which is really the only punishment the NCAA can administer, you have to impact the members of the program...the players. It's not like everyone who deserves a football scholarship now can get one.Â
I wonder how much pressure was put on Paterno by the administration to 'win at any cost'? Partial scapegoat?
@timsshop By 1998 Paterno was a "living legend" on the University, if anything he would be the one doing the pressuring...
@virtual anomaly..... agreed
It's not enough. They should bulldoze the stadium and practice facilities. People stand by and do the very minimum, burn em. This is CHILD RAPE, idiots.Â
They should permanetly bar Penn state from ever having a Football program again. Children were knowingly being raped there for years BECAUSE of their Football program and who they had leading it.
 @Jon H Hey! Why stop there. Let's bulldoze the whole campus, pretend that PSU never existed and revoke all the degrees that were earned there.
 @Gino Good point Gino. We can pretend that PSU never existed...just like Paterno and the Administration from the President to the Sports Director pretended that the rape of little boys never existed.
@sorbothegeek @Gino Good point sorbo...
The running narrative from PSU alumni is that "it's not a football problem." That assertion is ridiculous. I've never seen a student athlete who picked up a felony criminal conviction argue to his coach that "hey, it's not a football problem." Why? Because that argument has no merit.Â
 @GeorgeG. Indeed...
And - given the "sterling character" of the leaders in this case, how many other lesser men at lesser institutions also hidden moral lacks - for the good of the team?
I would not be surprised if other scandals like this (of many moral forms) come to the surface in the next few years.
@GeorgeG. Good point, to elaborate, they swept this under the rug so that their football program wouldn't receive negative attention....I call that a football problem.
So where is the 60 mil going? Why punish the students? And expect a huge drop in enrollment. With a 4 year ban, why would any young man who is aspiring to be a football player, even consider Penn State now?
 @Robinsnest "The money must be paid into an endowment for external programs preventing child sexual abuse or assisting victims and may not be used to fund such programs at Penn State." I think the fact that good football players won't be going to Penn State now is the point of the punishment.
The students did nothing wrong yet they are the ones who suffer the consequences.
 @09Ultra I gotta say, that comment says volumes about the vapid nature of America. The students will not suffer, college is about education, not partying up at the football game. If you actually think that the students will be "suffering" consequences we need to get a new word to replace "suffering".Â
 @09Ultra It is unfortunate that so many alumni (of MANY universities, not just Penn State) contribute to their universities due to the football programs. It's an example of how skewed people's priorities are (and that's not a slam against college football...I enjoy it as well). As a society we seem to regard athletic skill and prowess as more valuable than skills in intellect or the arts. I have no doubt the the students and other beneficiaries of Penn State will suffer from this, but that doesn't mean the university should go unpunished.
 @09Ultra the student athletes can go somewhere else, while the students can concentrate on their education. The real loser is the school, which will pay a large price. In money, lost revenue, and a reputation that needs rebuilding.
 @Bob42263 While I agree with you about the students going somewhere else, I think the real losers are the victims in this case. They can never get justice, and these things haunt them for the rest of their lives. Penn State can recover, who knows how many of the victims will have that luxury.
 @commonHuskyfan If there were 7 or 8 we know of, how many victims are out there too ashamed to come forward.
 @09Ultra Being a student on a campus which may not have a rock star football team is probably a small price to pay to deter other sports programs to hide vital information like this in the future.Â