Study: Pregnant teens need better school support
MIAMI (AP) - When 15-year-old Kali Gonzalez became pregnant, the honors student considered transferring to an alternative school. She worried teachers would harass her for missing class because of doctor's appointments and morning sickness.
A guidance counselor urged Gonzalez not to, saying that could lower her standards.
Instead, her counselor set up a meeting with teachers at her St. Augustine high school to confirm she could make up missed assignments, eat in class and use the restroom whenever she needed. Gonzalez, who is now 18, kept an A-average while pregnant. She capitalized on an online school program for parenting students so she could stay home and take care of her baby during her junior year. She returned to school her senior year and graduated with honors in May.
But Gonzalez is a rare example of success among pregnant students. Schools across the country are divided over how to handle them, with some schools kicking them out or penalizing students for pregnancy-related absences. And many schools say they can't afford costly support programs, including tutoring, child care and transportation for teens who may live just a few miles from school but still too far to walk while pregnant or with a small child.
Nearly 400,000 girls and young women between 15 and 19 years old gave birth in 2010, a rate of 34 per 1,000, according to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.
Those statistics have led child advocates to push for greater adherence to a1972 law that bans sex discrimination in federally funded education programs and activities, according to a new report by the National Women's Law Center.
Fatima Goss Graves, the center's vice president of education and employment, says offering pregnant teens extra support would ultimately save taxpayers money by helping them become financially independent and not dependent on welfare.
But budget cuts have eaten into such efforts.
California lawmakers slashed a successful program for such students in 2008, ruling it was no longer mandatory, and allowed school districts to use the money for other programs.
More than 100,000 pregnant and parenting students have participated in the program that helps them with classwork and connects them with social services. It boasted a 73 percent graduation rate in 2010 - close to the state's normal rate - and advocates said participants were less reliant on welfare and less likely to become pregnant again. That compares to several counties where only 30 percent of pregnant and parenting teens graduated.
"It's unfortunate that this effective program fell prey to the enormous budget challenges we are facing as a state," said State Superintendent of Public Instruction Tom Torlakson.
Three years ago in Wisconsin, cost-cutting lawmakers dropped a requirement for school districts to give pregnant students who live within two miles of a school building free rides to school. The requirement had been part of an effort to improve access to education and reduce infant mortality rates.
Less than half of the states have programs that send home assignments to homebound or hospitalized student parents, according to the study.
In almost half of the states, including Idaho, Nevada, Nebraska, South Dakota and Utah, the definition of excused absences is not broad enough to include pregnant and parenting students. That typically results in a patchwork of policies where some school districts don't excuse absences even if the student is in the hospital giving birth, according to the study.
But a few states have developed programs to help improve graduate rates among pregnant girls and young mothers.
In Washington, D.C., caseworkers in the New Heights Teen Parent Program often stand by the school entrance or text pregnant students and young moms to make sure they are attending classes.
When students do miss school, caseworkers take them homework assignments. About 600 students participate in the program which also helps students with housing, child care and parenting skills. But the $1.6 million federal grant funding the program runs out next year and officials said they don't have a clear future funding source.
Roughly 4,500 male and female student parents participated in a Pennsylvania program last year where case workers helped them balance school and child care. Nearly 1,300 graduated or received an equivalent, state officials said. The ELECT program, which started in 1990 as a partnership between state child welfare and education officials, monitors students' attendance, coordinates summer programs and links them with support systems in the community.
Florida allows pregnant and parenting students to receive homebound instruction and lays out a clear process to make up missed work. The state also gives those students the option of taking online classes.
In St. Johns County, where Gonzalez lives, the school district provides free day care for teen moms and bus transportation for students and their children.
Pregnant students are often stereotyped as low-achievers, but advocates say pregnancy actually motivates some to do better in school.
Gonzalez, whose daughter is now 2, said her grades improved after she became pregnant.
"I did push myself a lot harder and I made sure that I wasn't going to be that statistic," said Gonzalez, who is now married and pursuing a nursing degree.
A guidance counselor urged Gonzalez not to, saying that could lower her standards.
Instead, her counselor set up a meeting with teachers at her St. Augustine high school to confirm she could make up missed assignments, eat in class and use the restroom whenever she needed. Gonzalez, who is now 18, kept an A-average while pregnant. She capitalized on an online school program for parenting students so she could stay home and take care of her baby during her junior year. She returned to school her senior year and graduated with honors in May.
But Gonzalez is a rare example of success among pregnant students. Schools across the country are divided over how to handle them, with some schools kicking them out or penalizing students for pregnancy-related absences. And many schools say they can't afford costly support programs, including tutoring, child care and transportation for teens who may live just a few miles from school but still too far to walk while pregnant or with a small child.
Nearly 400,000 girls and young women between 15 and 19 years old gave birth in 2010, a rate of 34 per 1,000, according to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.
Those statistics have led child advocates to push for greater adherence to a1972 law that bans sex discrimination in federally funded education programs and activities, according to a new report by the National Women's Law Center.
Fatima Goss Graves, the center's vice president of education and employment, says offering pregnant teens extra support would ultimately save taxpayers money by helping them become financially independent and not dependent on welfare.
But budget cuts have eaten into such efforts.
California lawmakers slashed a successful program for such students in 2008, ruling it was no longer mandatory, and allowed school districts to use the money for other programs.
More than 100,000 pregnant and parenting students have participated in the program that helps them with classwork and connects them with social services. It boasted a 73 percent graduation rate in 2010 - close to the state's normal rate - and advocates said participants were less reliant on welfare and less likely to become pregnant again. That compares to several counties where only 30 percent of pregnant and parenting teens graduated.
"It's unfortunate that this effective program fell prey to the enormous budget challenges we are facing as a state," said State Superintendent of Public Instruction Tom Torlakson.
Three years ago in Wisconsin, cost-cutting lawmakers dropped a requirement for school districts to give pregnant students who live within two miles of a school building free rides to school. The requirement had been part of an effort to improve access to education and reduce infant mortality rates.
Less than half of the states have programs that send home assignments to homebound or hospitalized student parents, according to the study.
In almost half of the states, including Idaho, Nevada, Nebraska, South Dakota and Utah, the definition of excused absences is not broad enough to include pregnant and parenting students. That typically results in a patchwork of policies where some school districts don't excuse absences even if the student is in the hospital giving birth, according to the study.
But a few states have developed programs to help improve graduate rates among pregnant girls and young mothers.
In Washington, D.C., caseworkers in the New Heights Teen Parent Program often stand by the school entrance or text pregnant students and young moms to make sure they are attending classes.
When students do miss school, caseworkers take them homework assignments. About 600 students participate in the program which also helps students with housing, child care and parenting skills. But the $1.6 million federal grant funding the program runs out next year and officials said they don't have a clear future funding source.
Roughly 4,500 male and female student parents participated in a Pennsylvania program last year where case workers helped them balance school and child care. Nearly 1,300 graduated or received an equivalent, state officials said. The ELECT program, which started in 1990 as a partnership between state child welfare and education officials, monitors students' attendance, coordinates summer programs and links them with support systems in the community.
Florida allows pregnant and parenting students to receive homebound instruction and lays out a clear process to make up missed work. The state also gives those students the option of taking online classes.
In St. Johns County, where Gonzalez lives, the school district provides free day care for teen moms and bus transportation for students and their children.
Pregnant students are often stereotyped as low-achievers, but advocates say pregnancy actually motivates some to do better in school.
Gonzalez, whose daughter is now 2, said her grades improved after she became pregnant.
"I did push myself a lot harder and I made sure that I wasn't going to be that statistic," said Gonzalez, who is now married and pursuing a nursing degree.
Teens need not get pregnant.
 @Barlion what are you... the millionth monkey??
So let me get this understanding. Instead of teaching birth control{insurance] or a term I will get many thumbs down for swallowing. The girls should get special treatment ,thus encouraging others to do the same. So much of school money goes to "school projects' not worth anything .School dollars are so short,yet here we go with another group of "special accommodation".Â
 @Maynard G Krebbs the basic stupidity of your entire post is simply stunning.
 @tufa23 The basic stupidity of spending more money on someone else's personal choices and failures is what is stunning. Our culture now glorifies teen parents. Shame was always a good deterrent for teens not to get pregnant but in our country today, shame no longer exists and the tax payers are the one's on the hook for paying for others poor decisions. As long as we tell teens "it's ok if you get pregnant and become a teen parent. We'll pay for your entire support and that of your baby. Heck you may even get on TV where everyone can watch your life circle the toilet but at least you'll be making money for your humiliation. Because in the end, it's all about the money."
I was a Sr in high school when I got pregnant. I was forced by the school to quit, 2 short mo's before graduation. The father of our baby & I got married, he was allowed to complete his Sr year, I was not. We lived with his parents until he was working. Let me tell YOU, there was NO support for me AT ALL, I was a pariah and treated exactly as an outcast. I was shamed to my soul & never did recover from it totally. I did, however, get my graduation diploma by taking night classes. I did NOT want a GED....I wanted what everyone else had. Fast forward---my middle son's grad party was in E. Wa, they were bussed over and back. On the way back, one of the girls gave birth ON THE BUS!Â
 @Wishing1 Wow!!! Gave birth on the bus!?!? Nice community you live in. You got your diploma in the end so what's your problem? Don't try to make us "feel" for you because of the situation you got yourself into.
I am will to guess that the one thing this study did not look at was FAMILY. Those that find success in life most often have good family support. I do not care what the family looks like but to raise kids there must be a strong family unit in place. Without support for home most kids will drift off and get lost in life.
Whether or not teens get pregnant is not the issue being discussed here. While I agree that teens getting pregnant can be an issue, the problem of pregnant teens getting the support they need in school is the one being discussed here. It is a more immediate issue, as there are teens who are currently facing this situation, and steps can be taken to address this issue in schools far faster than steps can be taken as a society to address the more difficult task of reducing teen pregnancy rates. While both need to be addressed, one does not exclude the other. Steps can be taken to address both issues and have a more positive outcome than the general state of teen pregnancies now.Â
 @ohgosh Unfortunately, far too many people prefer to "address" the issue by enforcing blindness. They seek to "help" the girl by making sure she has the baby - so someone can adopt it - but refuse to pay for even the basic prenatal care to assure the girl and the child are healthy, and want to leave the education she SHOULD have gotten in the hands of the parents and the church...the least capable entities to attempt this.
 @OrcasThunder I suppose, and I agree with the majority of your comment, but I guess I don't tend to think of teen pregnancies as the product of a lack of sex ed at all. I think pretty often they are the result of a mistake and subsequent fear, or they are the result of the desire to have a baby, and the willingness on the part of the mother to accept the compromises and "do the best she can." Although, I do not speak from personal experience, so this is, of course, entirely my own removed opinion of the situation.Â
 @ohgosh "I'm not questioning the merits of sex ed"
But a lot of people do...they prefer the abstinence only variety.
 @OrcasThunder I'm not questioning the merits of sex ed. I think it is very valuable. I am just suggesting that one of the causes of teen pregnancies can be a desire to have a child. It doesn't always have to be a lack of education on the subject.Â
 @ohgosh "I don't tend to think of teen pregnancies as the product of a lack of sex ed at all....or they are the result of the desire to have a baby, and the willingness on the part of the mother to accept the compromises"...
Â
We are talking teens here...they are not mature enough to be ready to be "willing to have a baby" and "accept" the consequences"...heck, many women in their 20's aren't at that point yet.
Sex ed at least gives them a reality based basic idea of what pregnancy and raising a child involves...
I'll play Devil's advocate here. Things happen- teens sometimes get pregnant, lets make sure they have the support they need to graduate and hopefully go on to higher education instead of living off of the system for the next 30+ years. I had my daughter at 17- by the time she was born i was done with school, I was one of the lucky ones who had support. My parents didn't raise my daughter, they didn't babysit her all that often, and the government wasn't my babies daddy- my ex helped support her for the first 2 years and I have taken over for the last 12 years. Teens aren't going to stop having sex, but we can make sure they get the education they need to have a better life. Â
 @MomOf2 Kudos to you on taking the responsible road. Unfortunately, MANY do not. Happy Thanksgiving :)
Â
Here's a novel idea. Keep your legs closed, and HE can keep it in his pants until you both get out of school, have good jobs, and can AFFORD to bring a child into the world. I see kids have kids, and the grandparents end up taking care of them while the "kid" goes out and procreates some more. Of course, in today's society, the government IS the "baby daddy," and the taxpayers bear the brunt of this responsibility. Get back to good old fashioned MORALS, and our country might get back on track. Oh wait.......we're talking about liberal America.......my bad. I forgot for a moment.
 @Wolfen "Oh wait.......we're talking about liberal America"
Do you REALLY think that this didn't happen in your old "perfect" conservative America? Get real - I grew up in the '50s, and believe me, sex - and pregnancy - happened then as well, pregnancy probably more than eve now. And "sex ed" was a joke - if we even had it...in one class I asked "what is intercourse?", and the old guy teaching the class looked at me like I had advocated making peace with the godless commies... I never got any sex ed at home, and even the back alley was a hit/miss source of education. I overheard my GF whispering to a friend about some girl being "preggers", and knew of several high grade girls who had to suddenly drop out of school...
Quite frankly, I git better education on sex in the Army than I did in 12 years of school.
Your idea of the Old "Moral" America was a lie - looked good on the surface, but the real world was hidden away, shunted off to some place out of sight...as blind as thinking that a movie like "Reefer Madness" would be the cure to the drug problem.
I've been in your "moral America":, and you are welcome to it.
@OrcasThunder @Wolfen The biggest difference back in the 50s and 60s was that the parents were primary players in the situation because the government didn't step in and take over back then.
@Barlion @OrcasThunder @Wolfen Is that what you choose to believe. Percentage wise there were just as many teens having sex and girls still getting pregnant. Back then it was kept behind closed doors unlike to day where everything is out there in the news.
@OrcasThunder @Wolfen I was born in 1946, you do the math. I'm well aware of what the situation with teen pregnancy was. The bottom line is that it should be up to the family to take care of their pregnant teen ager, that hasn't changed in my opinion.
 @Jatok  @OrcasThunder  @Wolfen "the parents were primary players"
And you are how old?
More than likely the girl would be sent packing to a distant relation, or just sent packing.
The Shame factor was a major part of the reality back then.
 @Barlion  @Jatok  @Wolfen "Far less teens were having sex back in the 50's then they are now."
Really?
 @Jatok  @OrcasThunder  @Wolfen Far less teens were having sex back in the 50's then they are now. Stop kidding yourself.
Get an education first, then "SCREW" up later.
Teens shouldn't get pregnant in the first place, use condoms.
 @3rase "use condoms"
But not birth control pills or IUD's?
 @OrcasThunder  @3rase Condoms=cheap=teens can afford them. Birth control pills/IUD=expensive plus parents need to know=teens won't do.
 @Barlion  @OrcasThunder  @3rase Actually, DSHS has a Take Charge program that pays for teens and adults to get birth control of their choice, as well as an annual exam.
Â
They do not need parent permission to enroll in the program, nor do teens have to have parental consent for birth control appointments, it is covered by HIPAA.
Â
Â
Â
Â
Â
Â
 @OrcasThunder I was thinking about that but I couldn't edit what I said earlier, but yes those are also ways good ways to help prevent pregnancy.