Teen left brain-damaged by line drive will get $14.5 million

A New Jersey teenager left brain-damaged after being struck by a line drive off a metal bat while he was playing in a youth baseball game will receive $14.5 million to settle his lawsuit against the bat manufacturer, Little League Baseball and a sporting goods chain.
The settlement of Steven Domalewski's lawsuit was announced in state Superior Court on Wednesday morning in Passaic County. The boy, now 18, lives in Wayne, N.J. His family had claimed the metal bat was unsafe because baseballs could carom off it at much faster speeds than wooden bats.
"The Domalewskis are still saddened by the tragic events of June 2006, but this settlement provides them with some relief and comfort that Steven will get the care he needs for the rest of his life," said the family's attorney, Ernest Fronzuto. "He still can't perform any functions of daily life on his own."
Stephen D. Keener, president and CEO of Little League Baseball Inc., said the settlement guarantees that "Steven Domalewski will receive the lifetime care he will require as a result of this tragic accident, a type of accident that is extremely rare in youth baseball."
Fronzuto said the settlement precluded him from discussing its details, including whether any of the defendants admitted liability.
Domalewski was pitching when the batter rocketed a line drive off the metal bat he was swinging.
The ball slammed into Steven's chest, just above his heart, knocking him backward. He clutched his chest, then made a motion to reach for the ball on the ground to pick it up and throw to first base to get the runner out.
But he never made it that far. The ball had struck his chest at the precise millisecond between heartbeats, sending him into cardiac arrest, according to his doctors. He crumpled to the ground and stopped breathing.
His father, Joseph, a teacher who had been on the sideline with the rest of the team, said he and a third base coach from the other team both ran onto the field, where Steven was already turning blue.
Someone yelled, "Call 911!" Within 90 seconds, a man trained in cardiopulmonary resuscitation who had been playing catch with his 9-year-old daughter jumped over the fence and started to work on Steven.
Paramedics, who were a quarter-mile away doing a CPR demonstration, got to Steven within minutes, placed an oxygen mask over his face and rushed him to a hospital. But the damage had been done; his brain had been without oxygen for 15 to 20 minutes.
"Pretty much, he died," Joseph Domalewski said in a 2008 interview with The Associated Press. "It was just so fast. The thud, you could hear. When it hit him, that seemed to echo."
Domalewski was playing in a Police Athletic League game, but Little League was sued because the group certifies that specific metal bats are approved for - and safe for - use in games involving children.
Rick Redman, a spokesman for Hillerich and Bradsby, manufacturers of the Louisville Slugger brand bat, confirmed a settlement had been reached, but declined further comment.
An attorney representing The Sports Authority, the national sporting goods retailer, did not immediately return calls seeking comment.
Little League reached an agreement with the major manufacturers in the early 1990s to limit metal bats' performance to that of the best wooden bats. Little League said in 2008 that injuries to its pitchers fell from 145 a year before the accord was reached to the current level of about 20 to 30 annually.
The organization's website lists scores of metal-barreled bat models that remain approved for use in Little League play.
The settlement of Steven Domalewski's lawsuit was announced in state Superior Court on Wednesday morning in Passaic County. The boy, now 18, lives in Wayne, N.J. His family had claimed the metal bat was unsafe because baseballs could carom off it at much faster speeds than wooden bats.
"The Domalewskis are still saddened by the tragic events of June 2006, but this settlement provides them with some relief and comfort that Steven will get the care he needs for the rest of his life," said the family's attorney, Ernest Fronzuto. "He still can't perform any functions of daily life on his own."
Stephen D. Keener, president and CEO of Little League Baseball Inc., said the settlement guarantees that "Steven Domalewski will receive the lifetime care he will require as a result of this tragic accident, a type of accident that is extremely rare in youth baseball."
Fronzuto said the settlement precluded him from discussing its details, including whether any of the defendants admitted liability.
Domalewski was pitching when the batter rocketed a line drive off the metal bat he was swinging.
The ball slammed into Steven's chest, just above his heart, knocking him backward. He clutched his chest, then made a motion to reach for the ball on the ground to pick it up and throw to first base to get the runner out.
But he never made it that far. The ball had struck his chest at the precise millisecond between heartbeats, sending him into cardiac arrest, according to his doctors. He crumpled to the ground and stopped breathing.
His father, Joseph, a teacher who had been on the sideline with the rest of the team, said he and a third base coach from the other team both ran onto the field, where Steven was already turning blue.
Someone yelled, "Call 911!" Within 90 seconds, a man trained in cardiopulmonary resuscitation who had been playing catch with his 9-year-old daughter jumped over the fence and started to work on Steven.
Paramedics, who were a quarter-mile away doing a CPR demonstration, got to Steven within minutes, placed an oxygen mask over his face and rushed him to a hospital. But the damage had been done; his brain had been without oxygen for 15 to 20 minutes.
"Pretty much, he died," Joseph Domalewski said in a 2008 interview with The Associated Press. "It was just so fast. The thud, you could hear. When it hit him, that seemed to echo."
Domalewski was playing in a Police Athletic League game, but Little League was sued because the group certifies that specific metal bats are approved for - and safe for - use in games involving children.
Rick Redman, a spokesman for Hillerich and Bradsby, manufacturers of the Louisville Slugger brand bat, confirmed a settlement had been reached, but declined further comment.
An attorney representing The Sports Authority, the national sporting goods retailer, did not immediately return calls seeking comment.
Little League reached an agreement with the major manufacturers in the early 1990s to limit metal bats' performance to that of the best wooden bats. Little League said in 2008 that injuries to its pitchers fell from 145 a year before the accord was reached to the current level of about 20 to 30 annually.
The organization's website lists scores of metal-barreled bat models that remain approved for use in Little League play.
Really? I feel bad for the kid, but now I feel worse for the bat manufacturer. Ridiculous. I hope they appeal and win. This is what's wrong with America.
 @Bellevue Scott Agreed. I'm sorry, but I'm pretty sure that this falls under "acceptable risk" when playing baseball. Yes it's rare, but it happens. I don't see how this has anything to do with the bat manufacturer as it does pure dumb bad luck.
Would immediate CPR have helped in a case like this where the ball strikes between beats? This seems like more of a problem of parents and coaches no knowing CPR than with which bat was used (but then, I'm no doctor).
I feel awful for the kid, but come on!  There are risks in any sport.  People have horrible accidents, it's not cause for a cash windfall for cryin' out loud. Â
Well dang if you can sue for a thing such as this eventually all youth sports are gogin to have to be banned. Sue the helmet manufactures of foot ball helmets as football has concussions from rough impacts... sue basketball manufactures for basketballs that hit folks heads, sue bowling ball manufactures for shoulder injuries, soccer ball manufactures , seriously the line has to be drawn that if you don't want to risk injury 'do not play sports and stay at home and veg on the coutch... when you get fat and obese you can sue the soda pop and chip companies.... good grief!
Wait !!!!! Why didn't they sue the kid who pitched the ball, or the ball manufacturer, or the ball park owners for allowing the child to enter the park while there was a questionable bat being used, or maybe the kid should sue his parents for letting him play, maybe sue God for letting this happen, or the doctors for not fixing him, or sue the coach for not teaching him how to catch a line drive. This lawsuit is the craziest I've heard. Kind of like the one when an intruder was trying to break into a home and fell thru the glass window above and sued the home owner for injuries, AND WON!!! regardless of my nonsense God bless this young guy and hope he get better in time.
 @Pedro Torres Dude, did you even read the article... the kid was the pitcher and got hit by the ball! sheesh RTFA
This lawsuit is wrong at so many levels. We need tort reform badly in this country. Someone let this kid play and they need to take responsibility. It's not the bat companies fault. I grew up in an era when we hurt ourselves, we rubbed dirt in it. I have a friend who ended up like this guy because he got hit in the head with a baseball. My friend didn't sue. It was his decision to be in that field. What's next? Getting cut on the finger by an envelope and suing?
Get real and stop being sissies. Take some personal responsibilities for once in your sorry life.
You may be right about the lawsuit. I'm not as comfortable calling a brain damaged teenager and his parents 'sissies'.
At the end of the day, when we sign our children up for Little League, we probably aren't thinking they could die. Accidents happen, but if a parent feels that the accident was a preventable one, I don't see why we need to call them sissies.
When Karl Rove and the Republicans get "Tort Reform" we can go back to playing with Aluminum bats and Lawn Darts, and it will mean the end of all product recalls from injuries because the only rule and label that products will be required to carry will be "Buyer Beware."
 @Fred Slocombe I still have my illegal lawn darts!Â
 @Shelly  @Fred Slocombe Lawn darts killed three kids. I'm not sure why you would be proud to own an illegal set.
Â
http://www.cpsc.gov/CPSCPUB/PREREL/PRHTML97/97122.html
Wow suing the bat manufacturer? If he got hit in the face with a golf ball would they sue the club manufacturer? Seems a little far fetched, but I guess Im not as imaginative as some lawyer.
 @kbbcoop likely there is some nut out there thinking about how they can set somethign liek that up... honestly the only thing Made in America these days is the Millionare by Lawsuit!
There are a couple of comments here saying liability rested solely with "Little League".Â
From the article "Domalewski was playing in a Police Athletic League game, but Little League was sued because the group certifies that specific metal bats are approved for - and safe for - use in games involving children."
Â
Little League is sometimes used generically for youth sports but it's not, it's a specific youth baseball association. He was not playing in "Little League" but a separate and unaffiliated organization. They simply included Little League because they have an approval process for bats used IN Little League and this bat met it despite the fact that they did not provide the bat, sponsor the team or have any other association with the game in which this occurred.Â
Â
I'm hoping Little League's share of this was nominal as it really had nothing to do with them, it would be very similar to suing Road and Track magazine because they reviewed a Honda Accord and you got in an accident in one.
Â
It's a terrible but rare injury in baseball, unfortunately sports can never be 100% safe. Parents need to accept that when allowing their kids to play. There is a difference between negligence and an accident.  Â
You know I feel for the boy & his family. But I really don't think it's anyone's fault. I, like most on this story, do not beleive in this lawsuit. There should not have been a lawsuit. The other sad part (and I've been through it so I'm speaking from experiance) that maybe they should have let him go when God called.
 @Gigi Wow your Christians are just funny. "let him go when God called." What a complete and stupid statement from your part. Your crazy ideals that god has a plan for you and that includes people getting injured in sports are insane.Â
 @Gigi That comment is utterly despicable. "Let him go when God called." And you're qualified to know that God was calling, how?  In one sentence you've proven that money is more important than people - I guess we know what political party you belong to.
Â
F.Y.I. God gave us intelligence and a heart so we could help people, not so we could provide ways to get around taking care of them. Â If God wanted him dead, he would be.
Â
I'm sorry for whatever turned you into what you are, perhaps a quiet walk with God would help.
 @fyrefawx  @Gigi LOL, there is NO god!Â
because god solves everything, am i right?
Automatically im an atheist because i made a sarcastic comment that you obviously did not catch? That just goes to show what religion does to people and how immature they can be.
Just an FYI, my girlfriend is Catholic, so don't go assuming and making moronic comments like that in the future when you don't know me or anyone else that leaves a comment on here. If you think reality is living by the "word of god", you're highly mistaken and should continue reading a book that we have no TRUE facts on who actually wrote the book. When you find those facts, let me know.
 @bab5crusade  @BVU07mazdaguy You atheists are boring. Believe or don't believe, your choice. I don't proselytize you, STFU around me. Why are you so dissatisfied with your "choice" that you have to slam other people for theirs?  Reality?  I doubt very much you truly know what that is.
Exactly. People let religion get in the way of reality which is why i have a hard time even thinking about attending church. It's great to have a belief, but don't let it get in the way of what is reality.
 @fyrefawx  @BVU07mazdaguy  What horrible logic. God can not lose! I guess god did something good when a tsunami and earthquake hit Japan. It was god's plan for all the deaths of all those unbelievers, but it was a miracle for those lucky survivors. I guess it was god's plan for all those dead jews in WWII, but it was a miracle for those who survived during WWII. Do you find how illogical that stance is? Is God willing to prevent evil, but not able? Then he is not omnipotent.Is he able, but not willing? Then he is malevolent.Is he both able and willing? Then whence cometh evil?Is he neither able nor willing? Then why call him God?Â
 @BVU07mazdaguy Pretty much, one way or the other.
@fyrefawx@Gigi
"F.Y.I. God gave us intelligence and a heart so we could help people, not so we could provide ways to get around taking care of them. Â If God wanted him dead, he would be.
Â
I'm sorry for whatever turned you into what you are, perhaps a quiet walk with God would help."
The good old God can never lose logic:Kid dies: God had a plan. Kid lives: PRAISE GOD! Â
 @fyrefawx  @Gigi No I am going over the flaw of the logic that some theists have. To claim that suffering is ok and such an horrible thing to believe.Â
 @bab5crusade  @Gigi Guess what? It's not a contest to anyone except, apparently, you.
This comment has been deleted
LAME!
I really don't think that the bat manufacturer or the sporting goods chain should have been held liable. It seems like the responsibility should have been square on the Little League. They could and should have chosen safer equipment for the kids. I think people should be allowed to buy these high performance bats if they choose and it shouldn't be something that gets you sued over.
And I realize the only reason that the Sporting goods chain and bat manufacturer were sued is because they have deeper pockets. That part of the lawsuit seemed bogus.
What a crock. He voluntarily played in this sport. $14.5 mil is very excessive!
It's little league, and he was a child. We're not talking about enlisting in the armed services here. I played in Little League as a child, and I can assure you I wasn't thinking "I might die today".
Â
But yeah, $14.5 mil is probably excessive. Money won't repair the child's brain damage.
 @RightyTighty He's only 18 now and will require special care the rest of his life.  In case you haven't heard lately, medical care costs in this country have skyrocketed.....  I'm not 100% sure of the liability of those organizations that were sued, but I doubt this family would have been able to afford to pay all the costs of this kid's medical care for the rest of his life........if not from the lawsuit, then the costs would have been absorbed by the taxpayer.  And at least now, maybe those bats will be off the approved bat list for kids games and the chances of this happening again will be less.
 @Chris M.  @RightyTighty That's what DSHS is for.
So if a wood bat broke and he was impaled by it would they have sued the company because metal bats are much stronger? Maybe sue the kidâs parents who hit the ball because he was too big and strong. No because they don't have any money. It is time to set some guildlines on how much laywers can benefit from an imperfact world.
Sigh. Yet another frivolous lawsuit.Â
Â
It seems like anytime a kid gets injured in any sport, the parents rush to the nearest lawyer to cash out thier lottery ticket.Â
Â
Â
He nearly died and will require care for the rest of his life. Frivolous? We're not talking about sprained ankles. And I am certain that money will be going towards the health care costs that will incurr over this childs entire lifetime.
You might want to look up the word empathy in the meantime, and stop being so cynical and judgmental about others.
 @Jesse Um hello!!! DSHS is there to cover medical costs for catastrophic injuries like this.Â
I'm inclined to believe this was a freak accident and it could have happened even using a wooden bat were the ball to be hit hard enough and in the right direction.  I am really sorry for this boy and his family, however I can't help but wonder when the liability for accidents at the young age groups gets to out of control if the up coming generations will even have sports to participate in.Â
this stories makes me angry how can you sue a bat company because of a metal bat hits the ball harder.... thats common sense bro i played baseball for 15 of my 21 years of life and i mean come on. I feel bad for this kid and family dont take what im saying outta context but still this was well known and should be no means for getting money.... a bunch of BS is what america is becoming u can sue over anything lmfao oh u didnt disclaim these shoes did have shoelaces boom sued.Â
Confusing time line since everybody was right there. Sounds like its DADS fault for not performing proper CPR. Great Job Dad. Sue someone else because you cant cut it.
Â
""He crumpled to the ground and stopped breathing. His father, Joseph, a teacher who had been on the sideline with the rest of the team, said he and a third base coach from the other team both ran onto the field... Someone yelled, "Call 911!" Within 90 seconds, a man trained in cardiopulmonary resuscitation who had been playing catch with his 9-year-old daughter jumped over the fence and started to work on Steven... his brain had been without oxygen for 15 to 20 minutes.""
We don't have all the story. I am sorry this young man's life was basically cut short with a total accident. As far as the settlement, most will go to the lawyers and the rest will be spent to take care of him the rest of his life as he's not able to do so on his own. Should they have sued? I guess they have to - deep pockets can pay the bill, who else will? The parents surely couldn't, the son couldn't, and you have to be totally broke with no income to get help to take care of him, so this was the best option for the parents.
@Elaine2 I get frustrated at people that complain about "frivilous" lawsuits. I don't think this lawsuit is frivilious. A young man's life was changed forever and he is going to need care for THE REST OF HIS LIFE. What would you do if you were a parent in their situation and that was your child?
Â
That bat shouldn't have been used and that's what makes this a legit case. I don't think most parents would have thought that they would have to worry about what bat was being used. Hopefully this opened up the eyes of Little Leaguers and parents alike to pay attention to what equipment is being used and if it is safe.
Â
Fact is, this family going through this heartache has made a difference. This incident happened in 2006 and "Little League said in 2008 that injuries to its pitchers fell from 145 a year before the accord was reached to the current level of about 20 to 30 annually."
Â
Seems some changes were made for the better. I'm sorry your family had to go through this horrific accident and I'm am glad your son is going to get the care he needs for the rest of his life.
Â
Â
Â
 @Tattooed_Angel  @Elaine2 I totally agree. Thanks for proving there are still some human beings in this country.
This is unfortunate for this child and his family, but this lawsuit is frivolous. Exercise/sports come with risks. If not for the fact that the league was using a bat deemed 'illegal' there would be no lawsuit. Period.
 @dgruntled this bat was not deemed illegal.... Metal bats are used in minor leagues period i still own 2 of mine.... this is a pointless lawsuit
Â
"The ball had struck his chest at the precise millisecond between heartbeats, sending him into cardiac arrest, according to his doctors."
Â
I'm failing to see how this is the manufacturer's fault.
@myrongaines i agree. I don't see if the circumstances were with a wooden bat, how it would have been any different.
I don't know why it is but when a story like this pops up there are so many people who seem to think that the people involved are simply looking for a payday. Â Sure there are people show scam the system, those people are usually easy to spot. Â However we must look at the facts of each case. Â Look at it this way. Â The maker of a car claims their car is safe and will protect you in a crash. Â However they cut corners and put inferior components into the product. Â You as the consumer can not know this. Â You buy said car and get into an accident. Â Now you are hurt and what should have protected you failed. Â It failed because the car company misrepresented the product. Â They are then liable for damages. Â If they had never made a claim of safety or told you the whole story and you still bought the car, then they would not be responsible.